I'd have Kulik at least above Plushenko. The 06' version of Plushenko's LP was so watered down and that performance was just him mentally running down the clock cause no one else stood a chance.
Plushenko's program may have been watered down but he still had more expression than Kulik, a strong footwork sequence, better spins, and the 4Toe+3Toe+2Loop. Kulik's program had almost nothing in it. Great basic skating quality but virtually no choreography or non-jump difficulty and not an inspired level of performance.