- Joined
- Jun 21, 2003
Just curious - if you were judging who would you have scored higher - Rachael or Kanako?
Overall, after Kanako skated I felt exactly the way you said you did on the other thread. I thought that Rachael won the free skate (which she did), and that she p-r-o-b-a-b-l-y (?) won by a large enough margin (4 points) to be first overall at that point. But I expected Carolina to do enough to win the event, with Rachael second and kanako third.
Specifically about the program components...
FlattFan said:What Mathman said is fair, but it does not explain how Kanako inexplicably scored higher than Rachael on some of the components.
Interpretation
P/E
Choreography
I would have given Rachael higher scores than Kanako on Choreography and Interpretation. I thought that Rachael did try to skate to her music, while Kanako's LP (unlike her one-of-a-kind SP) was rather generic.
As for Performance/Execution, I always have a hard time understanding what the "execution" part refers to. Performance, I thought they both did well.