Everyone's known to underrotate (so I don't see the point of bringing Evgenia up as she underrotates way less than your average or above-average skater)
Anyway I think the people complaining don't really understand the purpose of a commentator - it's his right to state his opinion, this is just one person's opinion. Nothing more. Didn't change her scores, didn't change the fact she got more points, didn't change the fact her jumping layout was never done before and is unique, didn't change the fact many people hate it, didn't change the fact many people love it.
It did however create one hell of a messy thread on GS
^ THIS
Once again, as with the Carol Lane thread: nothing to see here, folks. There has been much worse said in decades by the likes of Dick Button, Sandra Bezic, Scott Hamilton, Rod Black, and even now not just Carol but also Tatiana Tarasova and Max Trankov. EVERYONE likes to dish and give their opinions. It's a sport of divas - female AND male. And everyone talks over each other.
Y'all better step away from your keyboards rather than sling mud at total strangers. This was entertaining for about 90 seconds and then turned into Much Ado About Nothing.