I still would have sent Mirai over Polina, who never once had to face the top Senior ladies prior to the Games. Juniors is a whole other animal imo, just not the same pressure and not sure but isn't there a time limit for junior programs? Apart from the 3A in the SP I think they are allowed the same jumps as Seniors. In any event, Edmunds was way overmarked in PCS and I believe the team was already predetermined. Mirai never stood a chance. But the past is gone and I hope that now Mirai WILL get the spot she was denied in 2014.
With rounding...
Mirai's NHK SP (one fall) PCS: 27
Mirai's Nationals SP (clean) PCS: 28
No real inflation - difference in PCS easily attributed to quality of performance.
Ashley's GPF SP (clean) PCS: 32
Ashley's Nationals SP (doubled -3T) PCS: 32
No real inflation, but no PCS penalty for mistake.
Polina's JGPF SP (with 2 falls) PCS: 24
Polina's Nationals SP (skated perfectly) PCS: 29
Nationals inflation of 5 points. OR she received more PCS for skating as a senior lady (juniors' scores are obviously held down until they skate as seniors + the obvious difference in quality due to skating without mistakes.
Polina was potentially overscored, slightly, depending on how you look at it. I'm inclined not to believe conspiracy theories. Mirai, and just about every other skater, controls her own destiny.
I stand by my complaint re your dismissiveness of Mirai's national title as not an individual accomplishment.
My complaint was nothing more and nothing less.
I was not comparing any sponsorship situations.
Honestly, I think faster than I type sometimes and my wording is not as precise as it should be. Might have meant to type "internationally" instead.
