Cinquanta on China Olympics | Golden Skate

Cinquanta on China Olympics

gsrossano

Final Flight
Joined
Nov 11, 2006
The following was sent to me by a friend in Europe.

To day, April 9, the newspaper “Il Giorno” published an interview with Cinquanta and Pietro Mennea about the idea of boycotting the Games in Beijing. Mennea has been a great Italian champion in track and field. He competed in five Olympic Games from 1972 to 1988, won the gold medal in Moscow in 1980, and kept the world record in the 200 meter for 17 years . He is now a manager in sport rights. He took part as a guest together with Cinquanta in a seminar on “Sport Management” at a University in Milan. Mennea, questioned on the idea of boycotting the Olympics in China replied:

“No I would not boycott the Olympic Games in Beijing, simply I would not have awarded them to China”. Cinquanta was asked the same question and declared: “I am against boycotting because it is useless. Besides I would like to tell Mr. Sarkozy: listen, if you do not come to Beijing., surely I will not cry, but, in your opinion, the strongest exporter of French perfumes would stop trading with China to boycott the Olympic Games? “ And to Mennea he replied: “Mennea is a good friend, a great athlete, but it is better that he shuts up, because one who says he would not award the Games to China, is the one who won in Moscow……. Mennea is an intelligent person, very successful also at university, but, his declaration, that I read, is not worthy of a man who lived the sport.”

Following this, Mennea attacked the IOC defining it a “Caste only interested in business” and added “The real problem is not China, the real problem is the caste of the IOC. These gentlemen on behalf of a presumed ideal make business and politics. Including the guy who reduces my sport career to an Olympic Game boycotted by the Americans. What is his name? Ottavio Cinquanta? let’s make it Quaranta ( note : cinqunata in Italian means fifty, and quaranta ,fourty) because it is obvious that this man does not know history. Not mine. And, even worse, not even that of Tibet…I do not want to talk of myself and I do not intend to answer to the provocation of Sessanta or Quaranta, one who, in 2001, voted in favour of the Olympic Games in Beijing, when everybody knew that in that country the human rights were not respected.” And he continues : “Even the IOC of the Quaranta or the Sessanta has always chosen to stay to the side of the strongest. Do you know why in 2001 they have voted for Beijing? Samaranch, the chief of the caste, was going in pension. To earn his place, the Belgian Rogge, needed the support of the Asian countries. They wanted the Olympic Games in Beijing. That’s all.------- As to Beijing, “The athletes must not pay because of the errors of the Quaranta, Cinquanta or Sessanta”.

Cinquanta added: "To stop the Games would be the only solution but the world sport would die in 48 hours. Because of the law suits filed by everybody, it would blow up. There are federations that live or survive only with the Olympic Games".
 
There was also an article on msnbc.com today that had an excerpt from Jaques Rogge, the president of the IOC. He said that in hindsight it was probably not a good idea to award the Olympics to China but at the time they had the best bid and promised all this great human rights improvements. Here is a link to the article if anyone would like to read it

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24043923/
 
I think anyone who has a brain will not boycott Beijing Olympics. There is absolutely no use to do so. The only thing boycotting can do is to hurt the athletes of that country which will boycott it. The game will go on and the human rights in China will not change one bit.

The only way to help China for improving the human rights is to make connections with this country more and help it open the doors and let the people in that country breathe more fresh air from the outside. The more open doors, the more improvement will happen sooner. I think it's a great idea to have a world event as big as Olympics in China. Let the people in China know more about the outside and let the people in other countries know more about China. It has always been one of the Olympics purposes from the very beginning (I believe) - as a peace ambassador and unite the whole world.
 
Last edited:
Why is it that the summer Olympics always cause such controversy? Hasn't it always been the summer Olympics that have been boycotted?
 
The Winter Olympics is just not the World wide event that the summer Olympics is. And the Winter Olympics' only venue that was boycottable would have been Moscow, but it was Moscow after the fall of the Soviet government. It has never been held in China. AFAIR, didn't Russia boycott the LA Olympics in retaliation? However, again, Salt Lake 2002 Winter Olympics was held after the fall of the Soviet government.

So I think it's partly just the luck of the draw and partly the lesser visibility of the Winter Olympics and partly the fact that many fewer countries take part in the Winter Olympics (and so there are fewer countries that have a hostile enough relationship to each other to trigger boycotts).

It's worth thinking about whether if the Olympics is ever held in the US again, if there will be boycotts of it due to our continued occupation of Iraq and approval of torture. Hopefull those issues will be resolved before we have a creditable Olympic bid by the US.
 
I personnaly don't think the Olympics should boycotted "just" on the base of the lack of respect of human rights in China, or because of what's happening in Tibet. The aim of events like the olympics is to bring people closer, and to forget for a while all the bad stuff going on in a while: it's sport and it's culture, not politics. Plus, if we boycott these Olympics because of politics, Olympics will always be boycotted, as no country has a completely clean record and a world filled with just allies. However, what is a problem with these Olympics is that human rights were violated to host them (people been expulsed from their houses with little or no compensation...). These principals ARE against what the Olympics are about and China should, in that respect be punished.
But the IOC should also be punished as they were the ones who gave the games to China, and what's going on was more than predictable.
 
what is interesting to me is we boycott all of these games, but the one in Nazi Germany went off pretty much without a hitch...

if there was a country worth boycotting... hitler's germany would have been the one...

that being said while I don't think athletes should be without the opportunity, I stand behind the decisions of others who are boycotting (such as Steven Spielberg who refused to help with the opening ceremonies, etc)
 
How old am I? I think Germany had been banned prior to 1936 for reasons I do not know. With Hitler's new Nazi Party, it wanted to show the World in 1936 that National Socialism was not a bad system. Yeah..........

There were plenty of European and American capitalists who praised Hitler. Money rules the waves. :banging:

Joe
 
Back
Top