Plushenko Will Return | Page 2 | Golden Skate

Plushenko Will Return

what's up with all yesterday's stars wanting to return? is it too difficult for some of them to even consider that their competitive days might be OVER? sheesh.

Note, it's yesterday's stars _saying_ they want to return (there is a difference). I'm treating it as a new standby line for the press when they have nothing else to say (like the old "I just want to go out there and have a good time").

Technically they can return and there's no benefit for them to rule a comeback out. I'll believe it when I see it.
 
Copied the quote from Ximena - a plushenko fan from fsu:

Ximena said:
About Plushenko's many combacks announcements. He did intended to come back late this season but he didn't realise that the surgery wouldn't turn out fine, which honestly was also his fault by exercising that knee way before doctor's advise, so his trainings got held back, it wasn't until the GP series started that he said he wouldn't make this season but the next.

As for his second/third surgery (3rd if you count the little 2nd one he did after the 1st one didn't turned out well) he said before New Year that he needed a second one and he was doing it in July, but then a month later he said he no longer needs it because he no longer feels pain. Now I don't know if the doctor has told him he no longer needs it or that it's him thinking that because he does not feel pain, he does not need it. This is the same man that took him almost 5 years to get that meniscus surgery so... my guess is that he needs the surgery but unless the extreme happens (like having two hernias by worlds...that man!!) he won't get that surgery

As for him coming back or not. The difference between his call and some of the other skaters is that Evgeni is training every day now, he is on diet, he has been consistenly skating every since Torino. He is preparing the programs, the SP is done, that and two more just in case, and apparently 3 FS (and wether you like it or not, it is Marton again). He has put on hold any other activities that is not regarding his skating. So he is doing what it's necesary to come back, and he wants to. So unless he re-injured himself (I so hope that does not happen) he will come back.

That 3ax in St. Moritz was wonderful and you can see his progress, he was barely doing triple toes a couple of months ago, now he has the 3ax done. He is being more careful about the quad, he said that he just begin trying it but was not even thinking about it two months ago, he knows he wasn't ready so he wasn't pushing it. It took him 5 months to get the 3ax, and he still has 6 more until he starts skating in Regionals events in Russia and 8 until CoR so if everything goes well, I don't see why he wouldn't get the quads and everything back.

Two weeks ago he did an itnerview where he said that he knows that it's very likely he will lose in some events and that some of the results won't be what he wants, but he is not worrying because his focus it's Vancouver 2010.
 
Thanks for the quote from Ximena, Jenny; it's chock-full of information. I think that last line explains a lot, i.e., that Yevgeny's focus is on the next Olympics in 2010, and that therefore he is taking the long view.

With 2008 Worlds just around the corner, Russia has a chance to parlay one entry into two entries for 2009, by having their one single male skater finish in tenth place or better. I think Sergey Voronov can do that, because he came in second at TEB 2007. If he doesn't get nervous because it's Worlds, he should be able to gain that second entry for Russia in 2009, so Piseyev probably does not really need Yevgeny to do Worlds 2008.
 
Never been a Plushy fan so the last few years have been nice with a semi-level playing field. I don't really care if he comes back or not- doubtful he will be able to seriously compete with the other elite men ... UNLESS the judges hold him up and continue to inflate his marks ... as history tells us they will.

Personally, I don't think he'll return unless the Russian Fed. offers him some gigantic incentive. And, as other have pointed out-- he has packed on a few pounds and not in great shape. Still plenty of time to get his body in shape- but not sure if the career related injuries will allow him to return to his former "greatness."

I've seen enough of his flapping arms, over-the-top "choreography" and bad haircut. Note to Plushy: please stay home and continue to make your fortune in ice show projects.
 
Right now the mens field it too deep. I don't think that there is a favorite going into 2010 and I don't think that there will be a favorite. If he comes back and actually does well, I still don't think he will be the favorite....not with a field that include Takahahi, Verner, Lambiel, Joubert, Wier, Lysacek and so on. I think that he won the gold, he won't win it again and he should continue on with his ice shows as that seems to be where his talent is right now.

I don't want to see that farce that was the 1994 Olympics where all these winners from 1988 came back because they were reinstated and they didn't really do all that well.
 
Last edited:
Besides the fact that I think it is highly unlikely he will come back and risk losing big time to spoil his otherwise stellar career.........................:frown2:

if one were to look at this from a stricly financial perspective, including potential future limitations that could result from continued injuries:scratch::scratch:,,,,,,,,,wouldn't i just make best business decsion to make as much as possible now doing shows while at the same time meeting contacts and starting to aet up a long term career either in skating (coaching, choreography, managing skater's career, runnuing a rink, etc.) OR an alternate career?:rolleye:

I agree with the former poster about the return of once retired skaters who end up doing poorly..................like in 94
 
If the men's field stays as deep as it is now, he would barely have a chance to medal, let alone to win again, under fair judging. It's quite likely, though, that the judges will overmark his performances. Of course I hope that this wont happen and the judges will do a fair job. I don't think it would be a wise decision to return, though. Skating in shows is the best job for him at the moment.
 
He's been saying this since Torino. Quite honestly, I'll believe it when I see him in Vancouver and not a minute before.
 
Paul hamm is going for his 4th Olympics ( I think thats what I heard) and he is looking pretty good. He too has his Olympic Gold All Around Medal. Most Gymnastic people think it is pretty cool that he is "back". I think some athletes are addicted to competing and enjoy the process. Plushenko seems pretty Patriotic and might be doing it for Russia. As far as I'm concerned the more the merrier. I cant wait to see if he can be competitive.
 
From what I gather about the two exceptional competitors, I would think Yagudin would come back for Russia and Evgeni would come back for a price. Not sure of this at all. Just putting pieces together. They may be the wrong pieces, though.

My own feelings about their return is totally irrelevant.

Joe
 
I won't be very happy to see the "judges' game" again because they want to keep him up in any circumstances.
Domnina/Shabalin will be enough about this story in Vancouver.
Let the best to win and don't start with the dirty game again, please. Even not for a big money.
 
From what I gather about the two exceptional competitors, I would think Yagudin would come back for Russia and Evgeni would come back for a price. Not sure of this at all. Just putting pieces together. They may be the wrong pieces, though.

My own feelings about their return is totally irrelevant.

Joe

Well I don't remember if that interview was posted here or at FSU but Tikhonov said that when Yagudin talked to him about coming back, he said it was because of the money. And actually I do think the whole for the money and for Russia applies to both. They are both very proud people and I think the fact that they're seeing Russian sinking on the men event (well now with Voronov around, hopefully Worlds would be a little better for Russia) is really hurting them considering they both were the reason Russia dominated the men event for over 8 years (98-06).

Thanks jennylovskt for posting my post from FSU here (I was so sleepy that for a moment I thought...there's another Ximena fan of Plush? hehehe and it was me)

I don't know if it's allowed to post YT links here, so if not someone tell me and I'll erase it, but for those who keep saying he is no longer in shape and doing 3t and that barely, here is his wonderful 3ax from 10 days ago in St. Moritz.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VijXI8yHKCM

Was he on bad shape and doing barely triple toes? yes but that was back in oct-nov of last year. Was he overweight (FS overweight I mean)? Yes, but if you've seen any pictures of him recently he has a lot a lot of weight, last week he did an interview he said he already lost 11 pounds but he needs to lose a little bit more.

As for him being overscored, I'm a huge fan of Plush, HUGE and I will be the first to admit his Olys scores were insanely high when in my opinion he skated so much better at the GPF 05 or Euros 06; but none here can say that he is now the only overmarked skater now, you can see a lot of other resutls which marks are just insane. Not only that, but the terrible job of some tecnical callers missing underrotated triple axels and quads left and right. So the overmark thing, yes Plush is overmarked in transition by a mile (and yes some of you think he is overmarked in everything else) but he is not the only one getting the overmarked scores from the judges at all. Is it fair? No (go ask Savoie), but you can not put him as the only one getting that benefit.

As for his comeback means he will again sweep the competition off, I think these last two years he is been away has proved that won't be the case. He has said so himself, he said that he is very much aware that he is going to lose some events (eventhough he won't like it)

I also think he is aware his time is passing by because there was interview to Verner from the russian press and Verner said, while asked about Plush that he was happy if Plushenko came back, though he knows Plush was not healthy but he wants him back to compete against him and because he is his idol and he told Plush that and Plush told Verner that Plush's idol was Petrenko and when he beat him at a competition Petrenko told him that it's normal because this is a sport and sometimes the idols are beaten. Will Plush, two-three years ago would have hinted the idea of him losing? Never, but I think this time he probably think it's high posibility.

I too was one that thought when Plush was talking about come back that it was pure talk, mostly because of his lack of training and then Mishin stated just the same. He said that difference now is that Plushenko is now present (this was Sept of last year) meaning that he came back to Mishin to start training seriously; and that's when it convinced me that he really had the intention to come back this time.

If anything, I think Plushenko is risking everything by coming back. He took his break being pretty much unmbeatable for 4 seasons. It's very likely (thought I will hope not) that he will retire on 2010 with nothing. In an interview to Verner he said something along the lines "if Plushenko comes back, he will have to win because any other place will look as a failure to everyone else" and it's true. Would his fed support him as they do if Plushenko suddenly starts losing? Will he keep winning Russian people, athlete, entertainer of the year if he loses every event? Will his tour get the success it had if Plush won't even podium? No. And really for someone (me) that has been reading pretty cocky interview of him for years, his last ones are very down to earth in the sense that he knows what's at risk; but he really wants to take the risk and compete again.

Unfortunately Plushenko is not one to care much about his own health in the sense that he pushes himself when he does not need to, and while he is being more concious this time about it, none knows if his body will take the full time training well and he may not make it back, but IMO if he does not come back, none would more sorry than him.

Sorry for the long post, I know most of you don't like Plush but like any fan of a particular skater, one jumps to their defence.
 
Last edited:
Thank you so much for the valuable information and analysis, Ximena!

Unlike to Sasha Cohen, Michelle Kwan, and Alexei Yagudin, I still have faith in Plushenko to do well if he comes back. It sort of like a blind faith, don't know why I have it. :biggrin: Now it has gotten your information to surport.:yes:

I think that your analyses are balanced and reasonable.

As of Plushenko's over scoring in Torino, it's similar to Evan Lysacek's 2007 Nationals. He deserved the gold, and got the over scores. It didn't matter that much if you think it twice because no matter how did you mark him, he would still win the gold. Of course, we don't want the over scoring become a habit for a skater, or it will sometimes affect the outcomes, like Lysacek's 2008 Nationals.

I agree that Plushenko will no longer be in the league of his own. But I believe that he is still in the mix among the best.

Why does he want to come back? I think he has the ambition, and still believe that he can accomplish something. A man who has ambition, is it a character that is annoying or charming? To me, it's the latter.

Wish him to take care of his own health and bring the fire on ice again!
 
Last edited:
Hello. :)

I'm totally new here. Was just passing through when I saw this thread and had to register so I could put my unsolicited two cents in the pot.

You naysayers that think Plush incapable of winning another Olympic medal are in denial. ;) True, his body had been through the ringer and he was out of competition shape for awhile, but c'mon! He's barely 25 years old, and he's already proven himself repeatedly to the folks who try to say he is less than he is. You guys are just hoping he's doing nothing but running his mouth about the 2010s because you know if he's not, your favorite stands a very real chance of losing. :yes:

I'm amazed some don't even think he deserves the points he got in Torino. You must have seen different performances than I did.

Oh ye of such little faith and abundant cynicism and criticism! It's not always about the money, and I say that if anyone has ever been capable of successful return >>> it's the seven-time National Champion, five-time European Champion, three-time World Champion, Olympic gold & silver medalist, and four-time Grand Prix Final gold medalist named Evgeni Plushenko.

I'm just saying.

No offense meant to anybody, but I have to speak up for Plush when someone's talking smack about him. :)
 
If he is judged to have better spins than Stephane again, then I will not recognize a true win. If he skates in that lack luster fashion again, I will not recognize a true win.

The man is a show off with superb jumping skills. He knows how to work the audience. It doesn't impress me competitively except for the jumps.

I'm one of those people who will just say yeah and forget about it.

By the Way Is he actually coming back?

Joe
 
If he is judged to have better spins than Stephane again, then I will not recognize a true win. If he skates in that lack luster fashion again, I will not recognize a true win.

The man is a show off with superb jumping skills. He knows how to work the audience. It doesn't impress me competitively except for the jumps.

I'm one of those people who will just say yeah and forget about it.

By the Way Is he actually coming back?

Joe


I hope so.
 
He is not missed. He should not come back and pretend he can hang with the young guns. His body has proven that it can't hold up. Honestly Evgeny, stop being delusional. Take your overmarked OG and walk away from the sport.
 
He is not missed. He should not come back and pretend he can hang with the young guns. His body has proven that it can't hold up. Honestly Evgeny, stop being delusional. Take your overmarked OG and walk away from the sport.

I take it you are not a Plushenkso fan.
 
Back
Top