Joesitz said:
Mathman- Skate America is 11 days after the Campbells. Those foreign skaters scheduled for SA are not about to do a cheesefest unless they stay in the country for 11 days. Think Campbells will foot their hotel bill?
As to the Usual Suspects showing up, I am sure they will think: Been There Done That - unless of course there is some money under the table in addition to the expenses and the prize money. There is no glory in Cheesefests. Money there is.
I don't think it will be a problem for foreign skaters who want to do Campbell's. The international men's and ladies' skaters scheduled for Skate America are Davydov, Maybe, van der Perrin, Dambier, Preaubert, Lindemann, Nanri, Oda and Voronov, and Carter, Leung, Hegel, Korpi, Ando, Mai Asada, Mao Asada, Volchkova and Meier.
I'm not sure how many of these are on the A list for receiving an invitation to Campbell's. (But I hope Meier is

)
About prize money, I don't know how important a factor this is to the skaters. Campbell's usually pays $50,000 to the winner, compared to the ISU purse of $18,000 to the winner of Skate America. Money under the table is another matter -- I wouldn't be surprised if Plushenko, for instance, receives an appearance bonus.
Is this a lot of money? Well, a recent article speculated that Arakawa received about $4000 - $5000 per performance in COI. Maybe a top skater could earn a couple hundred thousand for the whole COI tour. So $50,000 for one performance might sound like a good deal for someone like Lambiel, Joubert, etc. -- even world champions have to pay the bills.
Joe said:
And Michelle Kwan all healed????
I wonder if Michelle has some kind of long-term agreement with Campbells and Marshalls. Last year she dragged herself out on the ice to do both the winter Marshalls and the spring Marshalls even though she could hardly walk, much less skate.
Of all skaters, Michelle is the one who doesn't need the money. I hope they let her sit this one out. If Michelle skates, the format will have to be "not a real competition."
MM