G
guinevere
Guest
re: the travesty that was last night
I only got home in time to see the last 10 minutes - but that's all that's necessary anyway
I am so incredibly bummed out. I had a bad feeling that Carmen would get the underdog vote. As soon as I saw that Rickey was in the bottom 3 instead of Carmen, I knew he was gone - not because he deserved it out of the bottom 3 (out of those 3, Kim C should have gone), but because he doesn't seem to have a huge legion of rabid fans. Kim L doesn't seem to either (as she keeps landing in the bottom 3), but her performance was way too good.
I totally wanted Rickey to make it to the top 4 - thought that if he kept improving as he has each week he could become a serious contender: I think both Clay and Ruben - in a class by themselves in terms of talent and stage presence - are delivering the same performance every week; Trenyce is inconsistent; and Kim L does not have the necessary huge fan base.
At this point, I see Carmen making it to the top 3, maybe even top 2 . I refuse to believe that people will crown her AI over Ruben. THAT would be a travesty. But she has been given push after push from SImon and the producers (I still think that the last-minute country theme was to save her butt) to keep her there, despite her performances.
<blockquote><strong><em>Quote:</em></strong><hr>And giving Ruben a huge solo was a bit unfair to the others.[/quote]
Since I tuned in late I thought maybe they had done little spots like that for everyone . And did you notice who was in the video with him? <strong>CARMEN</strong>
guinevere
AI conspiracy qween!
I only got home in time to see the last 10 minutes - but that's all that's necessary anyway
I am so incredibly bummed out. I had a bad feeling that Carmen would get the underdog vote. As soon as I saw that Rickey was in the bottom 3 instead of Carmen, I knew he was gone - not because he deserved it out of the bottom 3 (out of those 3, Kim C should have gone), but because he doesn't seem to have a huge legion of rabid fans. Kim L doesn't seem to either (as she keeps landing in the bottom 3), but her performance was way too good.
I totally wanted Rickey to make it to the top 4 - thought that if he kept improving as he has each week he could become a serious contender: I think both Clay and Ruben - in a class by themselves in terms of talent and stage presence - are delivering the same performance every week; Trenyce is inconsistent; and Kim L does not have the necessary huge fan base.
At this point, I see Carmen making it to the top 3, maybe even top 2 . I refuse to believe that people will crown her AI over Ruben. THAT would be a travesty. But she has been given push after push from SImon and the producers (I still think that the last-minute country theme was to save her butt) to keep her there, despite her performances.
<blockquote><strong><em>Quote:</em></strong><hr>And giving Ruben a huge solo was a bit unfair to the others.[/quote]
Since I tuned in late I thought maybe they had done little spots like that for everyone . And did you notice who was in the video with him? <strong>CARMEN</strong>
guinevere
AI conspiracy qween!