Falls or step outs, Bradley was scored by the rules with proper deductions. The controversy, or the gift, is the UR uncalled.
I agree that the 1st Quad not being called as UR or even downgraded is debatable. But to me, my main concern is the overly inflated PCS in his case. Part of the reason is in the U.S., PCS has been evaluated very seriously and rigorously and are usually not inflated. I think very few people would be willing to vouch for the kind of PCS Bradley got today, at least not in the context of a rigorous competitive setting in relation to what other skaters received. It felt like Florent Amodio has just won the U.S. Championship.