First of all, Radiohead was originally going to do the Spectre theme song and actually recorded it:
https://play.spotify.com/album/6xEJ4AkNz1FFNmDT2rbEjM
Can you imagine if Jason skated to this instead? It's haunting and actually more of a contrast from his Piano FS. It's also more layered, which would all for some creative choreography.
Sam Smith is sort of a let down -- to me anyway-- after hearing Radiohead's take on it. My husband feels like the song lacks a power that is typical of a Bond theme and is especially a let down compared to Adele's Skyfall. And for it to win the Oscar over some other other really good Oscar-nominating Bond themes is sad. At the Oscars he also made this big deal about how he was the first gay person to win the Oscar when that wasn't true AT ALL (Elton John, his countryman did, for "Can You Feel the Love Tonight heaven's sake!). And when he was asked his thoughts that Thom Yorke was going to write Spectre originally, he asked "Who's Thom Yorke?" Again, the front man of Radiohead. It's OK if you don't listen to the band's music, but this is one of the top bands of all time.
So it's a mix of not liking the song and not liking Sam Smith's antics.
That said, I don't deny Sam Smith has a great voice and actually my first exposure to him was through Disclosure, the electronica duo, who featured him in "
Latch." His vocals really work here and it's not DOMINEERING like he tends to be with his solo stuff. This was my running jam for quite a while. Jeremy Abbott actually has a really nice
exhibition to this song. And many of you know Meryl did a
DWTS piece to this song.
Jason is a huge fan of Sam Smith -- learned that during my interview when I worked on the GS article -- and when he talked about working on the exhibition, he mentioned how excited he was about doing a program to mainstream music. So it wouldn't surprised me if he wasn't feeling the Apassionata program after a while and made the switch.