- Joined
- Mar 8, 2013
So? She does have UR problems, but her performance ability is great...
2016 JGP Mordovia Ladies SP
- Thread starter dorispulaski
- Start date
So? She does have UR problems, but her performance ability is great...
- Joined
- Mar 29, 2014
Umm... I think Nugumanova was underscored. The UR + stepout is about -3.5 pts. So where did she lose another 2 TES pts. vs. Konstantinova?
edit: Well, Nugumanova is just not getting the top woman benefits on the scores because Rus. Fed. is not banking on her right now. It's OK though, shes not age eligibe for the Olympics so she can wait out the bloodbath that will involve Tsurskaya, Honda and company.
edit: Well, Nugumanova is just not getting the top woman benefits on the scores because Rus. Fed. is not banking on her right now. It's OK though, shes not age eligibe for the Olympics so she can wait out the bloodbath that will involve Tsurskaya, Honda and company.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Feb 16, 2014
Why are skaters from Mishin's school struggling so much with jumps? He literally wrote the book on technique, after all.
a chronic underrotator, it is difficult to fix...
look at Mirai, Zhang or even Kanako.
I guess the season is over for Nugumanova, she might finish 4th or 5th after the FS, she will get dinged with URS
Panenkova is substitute in Estonia, also Samodurova is a sub right ?
- - - Updated - - -
or I might be wrong, Nugumanova has been moved to JGP Germany ? :scratch3: so Samodurova might get her spot.
Panenkova is substitute in Estonia, also Samodurova is a sub right ?
- - - Updated - - -
or I might be wrong, Nugumanova has been moved to JGP Germany ? :scratch3: so Samodurova might get her spot.
- Joined
- Mar 8, 2013
No chance, a UR is a big sin in IJS on par with single jumps.
Samodurova should definitely get her second spot imo.
I believe juniors with underrotations like Lozko and Nugumanova should never get a JGP until this is fixed.
- Joined
- May 2, 2015
Protocols: http://www.isuresults.com/results/season1617/jgprus2016/jgprus2016_JuniorLadies_SP_Scores.pdf
EDITL Bulgarian judge did not like Polina, but Uzbek judge loved her
EDITL Bulgarian judge did not like Polina, but Uzbek judge loved her
Last edited:
why them sent Liza or Sonya, if they should sent Stasya if she will take 2nd place overall here
3Lz-3t > and 3Lo > with the step out negatives.
Nugumanova still the same as usual, an underrotator...
I like the good judging here tehchnically.
Lozko is suppose to go to Slovenia right ?
Lozko should be replaced by Konstantinova
Nugumanova should be replaced by Samodurova
there is simple no place for underrotations, Its a big big sin in IJS....
Only four place if I remember right. Gubanova, Zagitova, Tsurskaya and should be Konstantinova.
- Joined
- Jan 1, 2014
I think Polina has the full package. Her performance skills will develop, I am sure of that. Of course she has a different style from Nugumanova who is more of a cheerful, outgoing performer. Polina may seem to be a bit reserved, but she is much more elegant and has beautiful long finished lines. Also I am afraid that Nugumanova won't be able to fix her URs. She is tiny now and usually these problems get worse as a skater gets older, grows and develops a more womanly body. I wish her all the best though. Hoepfully she is proving me wrong. She seems to have a lovely personality.
I do not agree, but usually if your Technical jumps don't do well, PCS will follow downwards.
especially in juniors, there is no leniency compared to seniors.
- Joined
- Mar 29, 2014
I think that Mishin is resting on some old laurels. He was great whith the Urmanov-Yagudin-Plushenko triad, whith Plush being one of the most noted athletes in Russia's history. He also got Liza to do one incredibly dominant season... but no more (I mean we are talking about a woman who was on her way to be the best jumper in history and now we have her talking about being insecure with her 3A... not even mentioning an unstable, easy 3T-3T). Unfortunately, I think that he is somewhat overrated as a coach.
Denise Richards she resembles very much.
On topic: I was blown away by Polina Tsurskaya again this year. This is Unsane. Having this height and keeping enormous jumps is incredible. And she's much smoother skater this year. How I wish her to stay healthy going senior. Then we'll have 2018 OGM decided with high level of certainty.
Lisa's skating does not impress me so much. But her personality shines bright. She's Elena Ilinykh of singles skating in the making.
No, 2 places each JGP
Zagitova, Lozko - Slovenia
Tsurskaya, Nugumanova - Estonia
Nugumanova and ? - Germany
Similar threads
