I agree. I would also just like to point out that Raf was the one who told Nathan to do what he felt best and let Nathan take control. So it wasn't really Nathan not going to Raf to ask him about it especially since Raf was the one who said Nathan could do whatever he felt most comfortable doing. And in this case that was 6 quads because he needed that confidence and needed to just put it all out. And I think just like any teenager, you get the most support from your parents and family and so I think after his disappointing short skate he naturally went to his mom and they had a discussion as any upset teenager would with their mom. And he pitched the idea of doing six quads which she fully supported. I do think Nathan's mom is very involved but I don't think she's too involved to the point that we need to be concerned that they're not trusting Raf and his coaching techniques.
This is exactly why Nathan needs a new coach.
I have discussed this whole thing with my psychologist friend quite a few times. And he believes that Nathan has been given too much freedom but not enough discipline.
Constantly changing his jump layout could be his idea, or Raf's idea. Maybe it is both.
Either way, this is not the discipline required to be successful.
This is what I mean being given too much freedom.
Maybe you can argue that Raf has so much trust in Nathan, and he told Nathan to take control himself.
But we are talking about a skater with great potential, but has not skated cleanly all season long. (LP at US Nationals came closest to be clean except the 1A)
Now, we are talking about even more freedom here.
I can see a coach letting a seasoned skater with multiple world titles take control, to a certain degree. But Nathan is not there yet.
After the team event, Nathan took control of his practice for a couple of days. He said he had figured out what went wrong.
Then, a repeat of SP as in team event. Do you think he figured it out as he claimed?
Letting a younger skater taking control can be costly.
To be all honest, I don't really like the way Raf trains his skaters. I look at Ashley Wagner and Adam Rippon. Both are very senior skaters, but they don't have the best basic skating skills or high quality jumps.
Nathan needs to improve in these areas now.
And additionally, Raf would give him so much freedom. That is just not going to work.
I wish I could be a cheerleader, but I truly see a ton of things go wrong.
At one point, Michelle Kwan wanted to take control of her own skating. That is when she fired Frank Carrol.
At the time, she was a 4-time world champ. And we know what happens at the 2002 Olympics when she took control.
My friend has been encouraging me to write a letter to Nathan and his family about all my thoughts.
He said it would be helpful. But I am not sure, judging from the reaction from this board...