- Joined
- Feb 17, 2010
Saying something loud and saying it over and over doesn't make it true. Your assertions are quite clearly not plain to see. If they were "plain to see," there would not be different points of view on these threads.
I think one point BoP mentioned that (I think) we all agree with is that scoring of elements, both rotation/edge calls and GOE scores, has almost as much to do with who is skating as it is how well the element is performed. Particularly for clean elements, I think skaters like Alina and Nathan tend to be a bit overscored compared to some of their rivals. I don't subscribe to the "Russia is evil" school of thought, but I think reputation scoring is alive and well, despite COP's efforts to break down the scoring to each specific element and PCS category.