Skating Coverage in the US good or bad? | Page 2 | Golden Skate

Skating Coverage in the US good or bad?

What do you think about american skating coverage on tv? I personally HATE US coverage. They show like 10 skaters (less for ice dancers) and most are American, as well as the top 3 and some random skaters that don't even medal. I watched worlds on Eurosport and the coverage was the way it should be. They show all the competitors and the whole event, not just some skaters. So the events are on for 3 hours or more instead of 1 hour. Eurosport is like watching an event in person. It is all live and they show every single skater or couple's performance. Why does the US not do that? All their events are pre recorded and they only show such a small percentage of the skaters and for ice dancers less. Does anybody else think US networks hate ice dancing? Why is ice dance singled out and get so much less coverage than the other disciplines( besides Synchro)??


Yes, I agree. I never liked the way ABC chopped up the viewing - a couple of disciplines per weekend. Here in Canada - especially the CBC - coverage has always been great. Even CTV before they lost their coverage, was excellent. The CBC always covers the whole event and one can record it if it's aired too late.
 
Until recently the biggest fault with US skating coverage, IMO, was the tape delay. My take is that if you cannot show it live or at least within a few hours of its conclusion (say, for faraway events), don't bother showing it at all. That's one reason why I'm really not disappointed that ESPN dropped GP coverage- I never really watched it anyway, having known the results of the competition weeks prior. Now, Ice Network provides a live feed (although I do hate that I can't record it unlike TV) of GP events, and Universal Sports.com covers portions of competitions that aren't shown on NBC.

A lot of people hate on NBC's coverage due to the commentators, but they don't bother me too much. In fact, I like that they don't ramble on quite as much as ABC's folks did. Although we get less TV coverage than in the past, the coverage we do get is live (or tape-delayed a couple of hours, depending on where in the country you live) and in HD. Personally, SA, US Nationals and Worlds is good enough for me. Plus, the competitors that aren't shown on TV can usually be seen either on a cable affiliate or on a live internet stream. That's something that just wasn't feasible in the earlier days, and that I think some people forget.
 
My biggest problem with USA coverage is they don't show the event until a week after it happens. Then they put American performances above the best performances. If your only going to show six skaters . Show the top six. Not the americans and top three.

I dispise the commentary of nbc and abc.(Nancy on icenetwork is Barable ) I some times feel I could do better myself.Commentary should enhance your awareness of whats going on and help you enjoy the things you might have missed or have no prior knowledge of. Commentary does not supposed to make you feel lost in superficial oppinions.

Love the euro guys. I watch a lot of 2008 worlds with their commentary. It was wonderful. Canada's is good too.
 
I really like British Eurosport's Chris and Simon, but I can't say I'm that crazy about Nicky Slater's commentary, particularly in dance. Nicky was a fine dancer in his day, but especially lately, he tends to fall in love with some teams, it appears because he thinks the lady in the team is cute, and then he talks too much and overrates his favs and underrates some other teams. He also hates on teams that are one spot above and one sport below the Kerrs. It's pretty funny most times, because if the team passes the Kerrs by 2 spots, suddenly he is fairly objective about them, or two spots behind the same, but if they are in close competition with the Kerrs there is nothing whatever good about them.

For better or worse, Universal Sports in the US covers the whole event live with video streaming on the internet. The Oxygen coverage of worlds was quiet good, but I have only gotten to see part of it, as it becomes available on the Universal Sports website, as we do not get Oxygen on our cable.

I really like PJ Kwong's coverage. I have heard that she won't be covering the GP & Worlds this year. Does anyone know whether that's true or not?
 
I really like PJ Kwong's coverage. I have heard that she won't be covering the GP & Worlds this year. Does anyone know whether that's true or not?

I don't think CBC will be carrying events on Bold this year - I'm not sure about Skate Canada,Nationals, and Worlds but it's doubtful we will hear a lot from PJ.
 
Last edited:
I wonder what impact the announcement of the USOC with the introduction of a new TV outlet for Oly sports will have on skating coverage. The NYTimes articles have reported that NBC was not happy, and neither is the IOC.
 
I wonder what impact the announcement of the USOC with the introduction of a new TV outlet for Oly sports will have on skating coverage. The NYTimes articles have reported that NBC was not happy, and neither is the IOC.

hmm that is interresting. I wonder will it be like tennis grandlsams as espn work with the tennis channel to show as much of live tennis as possible until the get to the finals were rights are reserved.
 
I think things are starting to change, however. The most significant was ESPN getting the rights to all the BCS bowl games, meaning that no major broadcast network will carry them.

I think there will be a time where the niche networks will be able to secure rights to all but the biggest draws in the biggest events.
 
Why is ice dancing the event that gets the least coverage? Is their some kind of bias against it?

Dont we see more Dance since Tanith and Ben and now D/W?
I think Pairs gets the least coverage at the moment. How would you like to be Evan and win the WC and not get shown at all? :disapp:
 
Why is ice dancing the event that gets the least coverage? Is their some kind of bias against it?

From talking to my non-figure skating-fan friends, many appear to be under the impression that ice dancing is (I quote) "not a real sport," particularly because it lacks the most obvious element to the casual viewer--jumps. Perhaps this opinion is pervasive among the general public?
 
With all the sports big here in the US we are very lucky to get any skating at all.

MLB, NBA, NHL, NFL, MLS, College football, College basketball etc...

We get Nationals, Worlds most of the time, the Olympics and Skate America. We are pretty lucky to get that.
 
With all the sports big here in the US we are very lucky to get any skating at all.

MLB, NBA, NHL, NFL, MLS, College football, College basketball etc...

We get Nationals, Worlds most of the time, the Olympics and Skate America. We are pretty lucky to get that.

I think russians and germans have same problem. But, they do find time to show all of them in between Cross Country skiing, KHL, Biathlon and all kinds of Gymnastics. All kinds of sports seem to be popular in these countries as well but, they tend to show as much sports as possible.
 
What I hate the most about US coverage is that there isn't enough of it!

Agreed. I wish Universal Sports could televise the entire Grand Prix. It doesn't matter to me so much that it wouldn't be shown on a main channel like NBC or ABC, as the Universal Sports coverage is far more complete. I also enjoyed all the Worlds coverage on Oxygen. Ultimately, I don't really care what channel the skating is shown on (as long it's a channel most people have), or even if it's shown live (I actually prefer a few hours tape delay so that I don't get as nervous). I just want to see more it on TV.
 
Back
Top