- Joined
- Sep 10, 2012
What a competition! The top10 skating clean 
With the first mistake being Stefania's 3T
I think that the placements were basically correct, I agree with all the scores except S/K: definitely overscored in the PCS (their PCS should not be higher than the Canadian teams for example), but they're being pushed as Russia #2 so
... I LOVED S/S but they weren't perfect, Tatiana and Maxim were actually perfect so it was fair to put them first, the PCS difference was obviously too high but the competition is in Russia so it was to be expected 
One pair I thought was a bit underscored in PCS was L/S: I really enjoyed their program even with the mistakes... Why was their PCS lower than W/W for example? :scratch:

With the first mistake being Stefania's 3T
I think that the placements were basically correct, I agree with all the scores except S/K: definitely overscored in the PCS (their PCS should not be higher than the Canadian teams for example), but they're being pushed as Russia #2 so
... I LOVED S/S but they weren't perfect, Tatiana and Maxim were actually perfect so it was fair to put them first, the PCS difference was obviously too high but the competition is in Russia so it was to be expected 
One pair I thought was a bit underscored in PCS was L/S: I really enjoyed their program even with the mistakes... Why was their PCS lower than W/W for example? :scratch:
In fact, a lot of the pairs teams were pretty on... possibly the cleanest pairs SP I've seen in a while.