2013 Worlds Ladies FS | Page 77 | Golden Skate

2013 Worlds Ladies FS

pangtongfan said:
Well the Worlds are right after the Games and going to the 2010 Worlds was much harder for her than anything I am sure, so why wouldnt she atleast go to the 2014 Worlds only a month later. I also think the allure of competing at an Olympics at home, and possibly trying to match Henjie's feat of 3 straight Golds (if she wins in Sochi, which is obviously a good chance) would be too much to pass up, but that is less certain.
Click to expand...

I'm a huge Yuna fan, but even I don't believe she has a superhuman body and boundless motivation. She'll be 27 by 2018. It's doubtful her body will allow her, and let's not even talk of motivation. It took a long time of soul-searching after Vancouver before she regained her competitive fire. After Sochi, I can't imagine her wanting to go for it again.
 
Eclair said:
Okay let me be more clear. You explained that you think it's unfair that top skaters wouldn't be allowed to compete at Olympics because of the 2-3 spots restrinction of their country, while lesser skaters are able to compete there and therefore you complained about Kim winning 3 spots for Korea.
I found this view inapproriate and explained that Kim won them faire and square, everyone had the same chances of doing so and this principle of restricled spots also apply for World championships, since very good skaters from e.g. Japan won't have a chance to go there while less good skaters from countries were figure skating is not similarily popular are able to attend. Now I asked, if it bothers you so much for the Olympics, does this rule bother you for Words too? And if yes, what you would change? The only possibility for seeing only the best regardless of nationality is to only take the best and exclude the less good skaters from minor figure skating countries. I wouldn't want that because it would take away the diversity and would end up excluding minor figure skating countries completely. Not to mention to take away any chance of them developing a decent skater. So no, I don't believe any other country deserves more spots at Sochi instead of Korea, becuase it has been won faire and square.
Click to expand...
I never said it was "unfair". and I still don't know what you are talking about. Please don't make up stuff I didn't say.
 
Krislite said:
The Russian girls had every opportunity and all the talent in the world to win three spots, but they squandered it.
Click to expand...

Yup, we Americans are FAR too familiar with this feeling...honestly, though, Sotnikova and Tuktamysheva weren't bad - top 10 in debut is pretty good...but this was a really deep field and they sealed their fate by being so far back in the SP...
 
http://asia.eurosport.com/figure-skating/yuna-reigns-supreme-at-worlds_sto3670195/story.shtml

"I have been in the worlds since 2007 and I have both good and bad memories," said Kim. "I had feeling this could be my last world championships and because I delivered good results, I am very happy."

Maybe this is why Yu-na seemed very quiet and didn't smile very much after the performance and winning the title. Thinking that this will be her last world championship, maybe she seemed "too(?!)" calm and contemplative for a person who just won a world title.
 
Krislite said:
I'm a huge Yuna fan, but even I don't believe she has a superhuman body and boundless motivation. She'll be 27 by 2018. It's doubtful her body will allow her, and let's not even talk of motivation. It took a long time of soul-searching after Vancouver before she regained her competitive fire. After Sochi, I can't imagine her wanting to go for it again.
Click to expand...
oh really? I think we figured it out by looking at your pic. I think Yuna is extremely strong mentally. sHe might be the toughest ever.
 
I'm a little weary of the teeth-gnashing concerning the Russians only getting two spots for next year.

The fact is that they sent two promising young skaters and last year's over-achiever who has had a bad run. But all season long, people have looked to these girls like they are the second coming of Sonja Henie. The fact is they were WAY overhyped in relation to their talent and experience.

Yep, they're good. One day, they may even be great. But a perfectly respectable WC debut in the Top 10 should not be cause for weeping and wailing.

Give them some TIME to learn from this experience and to grow from it, and quit acting like they've disgraced their nation when they actually did quite well.

Remember Tara Lipinski was 13th in her WC debut. The next year, she won. The year after that, she was OGM.
 
She said could, not was, which suggests she atleast might go to the post Olympic Worlds. Will be interesting to see but most retiring skaters go to a post Olympic Worlds.
 
Krislite said:
I'm a huge Yuna fan, but even I don't believe she has a superhuman body and boundless motivation. She'll be 27 by 2018. It's doubtful her body will allow her, and let's not even talk of motivation. It took a long time of soul-searching after Vancouver before she regained her competitive fire. After Sochi, I can't imagine her wanting to go for it again.
Click to expand...

I agree. As much as I'd like Yuna to continue through 2018, we should remember that Henje was 15 at her first Olympics, Yuna was 19--and the three-time OGM had arguably less injuries than Yuna did in her competitive career. I don't want her to end up like Plushenko is now. The sport is constantly changing, and if technical standards progress anything like that in the men's competition, I can definitely see skaters like Gracie Gold and Kaetlyn Osmond upping the standards in years to come.

ks777 said:
oh really? I think we figured it out by looking at your pic. I think Yuna is extremely strong mentally. sHe might be the toughest ever.
Click to expand...

Sometimes, the body can't do what the mind wants it to do. We learned that with Michelle, or don't you remember?
 
hurrah said:
And incidentally, technically speaking, Mao has just become the first woman to land 7 triples in history.
Click to expand...
Absolutely not.

Elaine Zayak - The reason why the Zayak rule came into being. Her 1982 program included 2Lz/3T, 3T/2Lp, a number of other 3T, and one or two 3S

Midori Ito. 88 Olympics - lutz, flip, 2 salchows, 3T/3T, and loop. 89 Worlds - 1st 3A by a lady, lutz, flip, loop, salchow, and 3T/3T
 
ks777 said:
I never said it was "unfair". and I still don't know what you are talking about. Please don't make up stuff I didn't say.
Click to expand...

Well pardon me if I summarized you comments: 'Korea getting 3 spots is kinda dumb. I mean, they don't really need 3 spots. They need to change the rule. '

'well if korea had another skater competing, then they wouldn't have earned 3 spots.'

and
'I am sorry but I'd rather see Russia get 3 spots than Korea.'

wrongly by stating that you find it unfair that top skaters won't be able to attend Olympics because of the spots restriction rule, while less good skaters from minor figure skating country will go.
I merely wanted to explain why I'm not your opinion, but if you don't find the issue unfair I don't get what your comments are about.
 
hurrah said:
Thanks for that information!

So, to rectify my previous comment, Mao has become the third lady to do a (more or less) seven triple program with all six jumps, the last successful attempt being 22 years ago, when Mao herself was not yet born.
Click to expand...

I can't believe we've had so many posts about this given that Mao didn't really accomplish this feat at all. She two footed the 3axel and had issues on the first flip - and I'm being charitable about the lutz. So there's no more or less about it. She simply didn't do it. Great for her for winning the medal, but let's not go over-the-top with her accomplishment here.
 
ks777 said:
I am not blaming the Korean jr skaters at all. All I am saying is that one skater placing in the top2 earns 3 spots is weird. I am questioning the rules.
Click to expand...

Before they changed the rules take into account the placements of the top 2 skaters per country (if the country has 2 or 3 skaters), the rule was that the countries who had a medalist could send 3 skaters the following year. In 1992, Chen Lu (China's lone entry) won bronze so China qualified 3 skaters the next year. In 1993, Oksana Baiul (Ukraine's lone entry) won gold, thus allowing Ukraine to send 3 skaters to 94 Olympics & Worlds. Of course, the country does not have to use all the entries. In 1988 East Germany could have sent 3 skaters (Katarina Witt won in 87) but only sent 2 skaters.
 
I find it very interesting that if Yuna Kim skated in the men's event, with the same technical score but increasing her PCS to match the men's factor of 2.00, then she would have gotten 74.73 TES + 92.00 PES = 166.73.

That's less than 3 points from Patrick's FS skate of 169.41! Isn't that crazy?!
 
draqq said:
I find it very interesting that if Yuna Kim skated in the men's event, with the same technical score but increasing her PCS to match the men's factor of 2.00, then she would have gotten 74.73 TES + 92.00 PES = 166.73.

That's less than 3 points from Patrick's FS skate of 169.41! Isn't that crazy?!
Click to expand...

Actually it is crazy. No doubt her performance with the same scoring should have beaten Chan's LP, not been 3 points back.
 
Yuna: for a long time a like Mao more than Yuna. But this competition changed my mind. I absolutely admire Yuan as an athlete, but even more as an incredible person: to be able to come back to top of her game like that, doing better day after day, under such pressure. WOW!!!!
Liz & Adelina: They have great talent, but for some reason, they cannot put everything together at the senior level. With Adelina's superb quality in spins, flexibility and strength,it is a very disappointing competition for her. She is also underscored a little here.
Zijun: Great achievement. Same age as Liz and Adeline, she for the first time outperformed both. Hope she can keep this momentum going.
Akiku: It took me a while to love probably because she doesn't have the typical "pretty face." But it is her performance that moves me. I also admire her for not giving up at the age of 27 (or 28). She is also a true inspiration. Her LP this season is so dynamic and touching. Hope she mades a comeback next season.
 
pangtongfan said:
Actually it is crazy. No doubt her performance with the same scoring should have beaten Chan's LP, not been 3 points back.
Click to expand...

Chan kind of did two quads though, and their technical content was different. I'm not defending anything, but you have to adjust for jumps done as well.

But to PChiddy, I say this: Now THAT is how you win a World title, dammit! :popcorn:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

labgoat
REWATCH CS Golden Spin of Zagreb
Replies
16
Views
2K
labgoat
labgoat
labgoat
REWATCH 2025 Talinn Trophy - Tallinn, EST
Replies
18
Views
2K
Walt FSHunter
Walt FSHunter
J
Possible GP assignments for women and men
2
Replies
22
Views
3K
Jontor
J
labgoat
REWATCH 2025 CS Lombardia Trophy
Replies
19
Views
4K
cocteautwin
cocteautwin
labgoat
REWATCH 2025 CS Warsaw Cup
Replies
0
Views
505
labgoat
labgoat
Back
Top