OMG haha... I did not make any criticism, I gave a personal opinion about tastes! I repeat you again, please read and interpret WELL because it seems you have trouble doing it!
OK, and my oppinion is, that your oppinion is pointless.
It is just like discussing about colors:
I like purple, you like green, Jimmy loves red and Zagi tiger-pattern. And than you came in telling, that Zagi would fit elephant-gray better.
and the way she is telling the story is just charming.
Maybe They both love France? 