Dream Judging Panel for AI

[Piel]

i am getting tired of the sweet gal, nasty guy, somewhere in the middle guy formula that all of the talent shows seem to be using. If you could choose the judges for "American Idol" who would it be? Choose five.

I think I would choose ......
Suzanne Depasse from Motown
Carole King from the Brill Building gang
Barry or Robin Gibb of the BeeGees
LA Reid or Kenneth (Babyface) Edmonds
Dr.Dre

 

[Tonichelle]

Simon and Randy stay, dump Paula... that's what I'd like to see...

 

[SeaniBu]

Fun concept.

I am with Toni, but Simon doesn't bother me with the judging as much as the comments before and after. And I really like Randy minus the "yo dawg" comments. I don't think Paula brings much to the table but blubbering and shlapshick hamm it up."


Simon stays
Randy stays
Puffy or Dre would be good:agree:
Someone from the country world that has broad tastes like Faith or LeAnne
And it is rather weird, Ray Manzarek

 

[Ladskater]

I think all three "judges" need to be replaced. They are getting a little tiresome. I think Simon is bored most of the time with the whole project and Paula obviously needs the gig, but goes overboard. Randy is just annoying.

I think one of the Bee Gees would be a great idea.

 

[CzarinaAnya]

Barry Gibb would be awesome. His brother, Robin is a whiner, so I wouldn't have him there.

I had said I wanted David Foster to replace Simon, if Simon didn't want to be there anymore. That was before I knew he was judging in this show.

How about two women judges and one guy???

 

[Tonichelle]

no, one drama queen is enough, I don't think I could handle two.

I think if Paula were out, Simon wouldn't be so annoyed/bored...

 

[CzarinaAnya]

no, one drama queen is enough, I don't think I could handle two.

I think if Paula were out, Simon wouldn't be so annoyed/bored...

LOL! I didn't think of that. Very good point.

 

[Grgranny]

I think Liza Minelli would be funny!