Debi Thomas' Carmen, Scott & Moir Carmen, Evgeni Plushenko's Carmen, Yuna Kim skated to Carmen, Michelle Kwan skated to Carmen, Mao Asada to Carmen, Mirai Nagasu to Carmen, Sasha Cohen to Carmen, Adelina Sotnikova to Carmen, Meryl Davis & Charlie White to POTO,
Akiko Suzuku to POTO, Gracie Gold to POTO, Patrick Chan to POTO, Brian Boitano to POTO, Alexia Paganini to POTO, Daisuke Takahashi to POTO, Yuzuru Hanyu to POTO.. I could go on and on. There were maaaaaany memorable performances
Should've clarified that I meant Ladies when asking how many Carmen and Phantom programs are remembered but I thought it was obvious since Dani G's interview was discussed and he was talking about Alina's programs BY listing who skated to C and P does not make the programs memorable They were not. Thomas skated to Carmen the same year Witt did and Witt's is remembered as the best not because she won that competition but because she managed to portray it best character-wise. Sorry but Sotnikova ?? With all my love for Kwan her program was very average and forgettable and so was Asada's and Cohen's. BTW re ice dancers performing Carmen, you missed the best of all Bestemianova and Bukin's Carmen. If you have not watched it, please do, it's brilliant and just as perfect as Torvill and Dean's legendary Bolero. They completely owned the music.
I see where Dani G was coming from when he discussed his C and P programs for Alina. While I personally don't think the programs were the BOAT, I certainly think they were memorable enough to pop in mind within the span of 3-4 years...that was his whole point.