The Shibs have proved all their detractors who were watching with glee when they would place low and waiting for them to retire ever since they dared beat more favored teams at 2011 Worlds wrong. All the calls for them to retire, for Maia to find a new partner, all the predictions that they will lose a Worlds spot after 2014, all the talk about them never being a true contender again...the Shibs just told them to shove it. They performed the impossible and made an honest-to-God comeback in Ice Dance. That never happens in this discipline where once you lose favor, you lose it forever and you keep going down further and further. They showed the whole figure skating community and the world that they are a force to be reckoned with, and I do not believe they are anywhere close to hitting their peak.
I also love the renewed competitive spirit they showed. You saw that they were disappointed before their FD, and didn't let that phase their performance at all. In the past, Alex would stumble or Maia would not do enough to achieve a desired level when the pressure was on. I was needlessly worried all season because I thought they were due for a mistake like at 2015 4CC FD or even 2015 Worlds FD where they lost two levels on a lift, or various other incidences in the past. Now I know those things aren't going to happen again as they are on a different technical level than they were before. They are true competitors because even though Alex said their score didn't matter in the KnC, when they saw their PB of 113+ and the fact that they secured the silver and beat competitors who they had lost to for 3-5 seasons consistently even when those competitors made obvious and egregious errors, they were NOT happy. They are hungry and I cannot wait to see what they do from now to the end of their competitive career.
I admit I was a little sad that they didn't have a complete Cinderella story, but then someone on GS stated that why does this have to be the end of their comeback story? It's true. This page of their career is only beginning, and unlike some other teams who get the favored judges'/fan/forum pet treatment, the Shibs has had to earn all their accolades the hard way. Those PCS and GOEs they received this season did not come easy at all and the judges are still reserving the best scores from them. The Shibs haven't gotten any favors so any future and possibly surprising success will be due to their hard work rather than being an anointed one.