hockeyfan228 said:I think that the ISU will need to come up with a consistent standard for scoring the over-/under-rotated jumps. It's possible that some judges are taking it out of the GOE (double whammy), and some are expecting the devaluation by the caller -- i.e. from 3L to 2L -- to take care of it. Also, there seem to be variations in the CCoSp scoring more than some other spins. For the program elements, while most judges are relatively consistent among elements, they can be pretty far apart from each other, by 3 or more points on occasion. Sounds like more seminars to me.
I totally agree hockeyfan. I was looking earlier at Corwin's flip. It seems that a couple judges were harsh with a -3 on a jump *already* downgraded to a 2F. I would think the -2 would have been suffcient, and I could live with the -1. It's is so hard to say since this competition was not seen. But my understanding is the -3 would be used for a fall, or *major* problems with edge at take off or landing , and rotation, and step out, together. The guide say 3 or more problems of -1.
Maybe she did, who knows??
But, for the most part, they do seem mostly consistent.
Mathman- don't forget in your correlations, the 2 highest and 2 lowest scores are thrown out.
Last edited: