I, too, am car shopping. I had several models in mind, but then I received the Consumer Reports car edition (just released). My final two choices are the Civic and the Corolla. Both received great scores and are in the right price range. Plus, both have very good resale value. I am leaning toward the Civic because it looks sharper, but it will depend on the test drives.
I really wanted to look into the Saturn Ion and Volkswagon Jetta, but the Ion received horrible reviews, plus the interior was rated too cramped. The Jetta has been completely remodeled for 2005! It doesn't look anthing like the cute little car it has been

. I am so disappointed. It is too new to have any ratings yet.
I currently drive a Ford Escort ('99). Not the sharpest looking car, but the best car I have ever owned. This is my second Ford and have not had a thing go wrong with either of them, except normal wear and tear. Because of this, I might look into the Ford Focus, which was rated the Best Buy for it's size and price range. I think this is the second year in a row it has received this award.