Note: I'm using the Ladies' event as the example in my post, but this is to point out that the North American competitive system as a whole is lacking, and no individual skaters or coaches are to blame for this.
Top 3 ladies in Russia this year:
Top 3 ladies in the US this year:
If you recall, at the last Olympics, Russia took both gold and silver in ladies' single, with Zagitova and Medvedeva. Fast forward to this year, they are now no longer at the top of their domestic circuits and haven't won any major competitions yet. Instead, younger talents rose up and made them obsolete. And these two skaters are the 2018 Olympic Champion and Runner-up, mind you; that would be like Mike Trout being relegated to some farm team next season. Unthinkable, right?
But this is not Zagitova's fault or Medvedeva's fault, rather, it is a merit of the Russian system: the ability to continually produce new talents. Bradie Tennell or Mariah Bell has dominating in US senior and junior competitions for almost a decade now. Most of the Russian girls win their national title for one or two years, and then they get surpassed by other, younger skaters coming up through the system. Now why is that?
The US system fails because judges and fans wants to give the crown to a skater they feel is safe. Ashley Wagner was pretty much a bottom-tier skater for a decade, and somehow fans were still fighting for her to go to the Olympics in 2018, and for some reason, the judges almost agreed. Bradie Tennell and Mariah Bell, while not as problematic, have also been in senior comps for 5+ years now. You're telling me that 2 skaters, who has been struggling in senior competition in that amount of time, somehow is winning Nationals this year??? Why hasn't USFS or Skate Canada been able to scout any new skaters from junior or from another developing region?
So let's look at some potential roots of this problem:
- LA celebrity culture
- Bad coaches
- Importing bad international skaters (Kaitlyn Weaver, Piper Gilles in Canada, Christina Carreira in the US)
- Awful scouting
- No development system
- Judges won't take risk
- Entertainment region (SOI and Disney on Ice is more popular than comp)
- Small talent pool despite huge population (???)
Top 3 ladies in Russia this year:
Anna Shcherbakova - 16
Alena Kostornaia - 17
Alexandra Trusova -16
Top 3 ladies in the US this year:
Alysa Liu - 15
Mariah Bell - 24
Bradie Tennell - 22
If you recall, at the last Olympics, Russia took both gold and silver in ladies' single, with Zagitova and Medvedeva. Fast forward to this year, they are now no longer at the top of their domestic circuits and haven't won any major competitions yet. Instead, younger talents rose up and made them obsolete. And these two skaters are the 2018 Olympic Champion and Runner-up, mind you; that would be like Mike Trout being relegated to some farm team next season. Unthinkable, right?
But this is not Zagitova's fault or Medvedeva's fault, rather, it is a merit of the Russian system: the ability to continually produce new talents. Bradie Tennell or Mariah Bell has dominating in US senior and junior competitions for almost a decade now. Most of the Russian girls win their national title for one or two years, and then they get surpassed by other, younger skaters coming up through the system. Now why is that?
The US system fails because judges and fans wants to give the crown to a skater they feel is safe. Ashley Wagner was pretty much a bottom-tier skater for a decade, and somehow fans were still fighting for her to go to the Olympics in 2018, and for some reason, the judges almost agreed. Bradie Tennell and Mariah Bell, while not as problematic, have also been in senior comps for 5+ years now. You're telling me that 2 skaters, who has been struggling in senior competition in that amount of time, somehow is winning Nationals this year??? Why hasn't USFS or Skate Canada been able to scout any new skaters from junior or from another developing region?
So let's look at some potential roots of this problem:
- LA celebrity culture
- Bad coaches
- Importing bad international skaters (Kaitlyn Weaver, Piper Gilles in Canada, Christina Carreira in the US)
- Awful scouting
- No development system
- Judges won't take risk
- Entertainment region (SOI and Disney on Ice is more popular than comp)
- Small talent pool despite huge population (???)