And I don't think Sotnikova deserved 149 in the long either. But I didn't think Kim deserved 150 in the long in Vancover. Inflation happens at the Olympics.
I would have probably given Adelina 71 in PCS. And Kept Kim's Pcs the same, and maybe raised Kostner's. But guess what. Sotnikova-still wins.
Kim deserved her scores more than Adelina. Just compare their quality of skating. Look at Yuna's 2010 performance and then Adelina's 2014 FS. I know it's not fair to directly compare them since they are from different events, but since you brought it up I don't see why not. ALL I'm saying is that Yuna's score was way more justifiable than Adelina's score because it was not a flawless program. I agree with you. I would've given Adelina 71 in PCS and kept Yuna the same as well. But GUESS what, I would've given lower GOEs on some of Adelina's jumps (some of them were definitely NOT GOE+3 worthy). I also would've lowered Adelina's SP score...by quite a lot actually. A LOT of people are forgetting what happened in the short program. Yuna was robbed right from the beginning. This was all planned. I'm not even Korean and I knew what was going on.