From andante online: Keonid Kogan
Of course they mentioned Oistrakh and Milstein too.
cd review
www.andante.com/article/a...m?id=19412
'Leonid Kogan in Paris'
Robert Layton
Beethoven: Violin Concerto in D, Op. 6. Mozart: Violin Concerto No. 5 in A, K. 219, "Turkish." Etc.
Leonid Kogan (violin); Paris Conservatoire Orchestra.
Leonid Kogan in Paris Historic
Beethoven Violin Concerto in D, Op. 61a. Mozart Violin Concerto No. 5 in A, K219, 'Turkish'b.
Leonid Kogan (violin); Paris Conservatoire Orchestra/André Vandernoot.
Testament mono SBT1228 (full price, 1 hour 13 minutes, ADD). From aXLX648-9 (previously unpublished), bTrianon TRX6132. Producer Norbert Gamsohn. Engineer Paul Vavasseur. Remastering Engineer Paul Baily. Dates aJune 13th, a14th, b29th and b30th,1957.
Bar Code:046772252
Leonid Kogan in Paris Historic
Brahms Violin Concerto in D, Op. 77a. Mendelssohn Violin Concerto No. 1 in E minor, Op. 64b.
Leonid Kogan (violin); Paris Conservatoire Orchestra/aCharles Bruck, bConstantin Silvestri.
Testament amono/bstereo SBT1225 (full price, 1 hour 6 minutes, ADD). From aColumbia 33CX1506, bSA2392. Producers aRené Challan, bNorbert Gamsohn. Engineers aWalter Ruhlmann, bRoger Ducourtieux. Remastering Engineer Paul Baily. Dates aMarch 5th and 6th, 1955, bNovember 19th, 1961.
Bar Code:40677262
Leonid Kogan in Paris Historic
Lalo Symphonie espagnole, Op. 21. Paganini Violin Concerto No. 1 in D, Op. 6.
Leonid Kogan (violin); Paris Conservatoire Orchestra/Charles Bruck.
Testament mono SBT1226 (full price, 1 hour 9 minutes, ADD). From Columbia 33C1059 and 33CX1562. Producer René Challan. Engineer Walter Ruhlmann. Remastering Engineer Paul Baily. Dates February 21st-23rd, 1955.
Comparisons:
Beethoven/Brahms/Lalo:
Kogan, Philh/Kondrashin, Paris Conservatoire Orch/Silvestri
(EMI) CZS7 67732-2 (1956, two discs)
Beethoven:
Milstein, Pittsburgh SO/Steinberg (EMI) CDM5 67583-2 (1955)
D. Oistrakh, FRNO/Cluytens (Testament) SAX2315 (1958, LP)
The last significant reminder of Leonid Kogan's artistry was a two-CD set in EMI's 'Artist Profile' series released in 1993 and principally comprising the Brahms, Tchaikovsky and Beethoven Concertos with Kyrill Kondrashin and Constantin Silvestri, though he was also represented in some subsequent (and, come to that, far from insignificant) Revelation and Olympia issues. The present discs offer an important addition to his relatively meagre representation in the current catalogue. His artistry was of a perfection and classical purity that silenced criticism.
His mono account of the Beethoven Concerto comes from 1957 and, like the Mozart A major Concerto with which it is coupled, never appeared in Britain at the time. The Mozart was issued in France but the Beethoven fell victim to the advent of stereo, and although it was passed for release, when Kogan re-recorded it in stereo with Silvestri two years later, it was withheld. It now surfaces for the first time 45 years later -- and 20 years after Kogan's premature death. (Had he lived he would now only have been in his late seventies.) Testament has put us in its debt by issuing it now, for it is a reading of the greatest distinction and even those who have treasured the later performance should investigate it. There is a purity and nobility here (as, of course, there is in the Silvestri recording) yet it seems to me slightly freer in feeling with a more improvisatory quality. Tully Potter's informative insert notes speak of it as 'one of the glories of its era' and there is a spirituality that you find in the greatest performances of the day: the David Oistrakh/André Cluytens version restored some years ago on a Testament LP, and the glorious Nathan Milstein/Pittsburgh version from 1955) -- but few others since!
Kogan's Brahms Concerto, recorded in 1955 with Charles Bruck conducting, was released early in 1958 but again was soon displaced by the set he made with the Philharmonia under Kondrashin only a year later. Kogan brought a magisterial Classicism to this concerto and an affecting ardour. The Philharmonia give him much finer support than do the Paris Conservatoire Orchestra, but this earlier account is still a performance of eloquence and effortless technical command. There is a natural dignity of utterance that is rarely encountered nowadays.
In the hands of the flashy present-day teenage whizz-kids the Lalo Symphonie espagnole can sound an empty circus piece but Kogan, with his impeccable taste, elevates it to something out of the ordinary, as he does Paganini's First Violin Concerto. His range of colour and imagination in matters of phrasing make the Lalo a joy. Kogan was one of the great aristocrats of the bow, and his artistry was served by flawless technique and impeccable musical judgement. Paul Baily's splendid transfers have brought us as close to the actual 1950s sound of the Salle de la Mutualité or the Salle Wagram as we are ever likely to get.