re. Denise: Well, THAT'S interesting, given how much she was going off about honesty at Final Tribal Council....:sheesh: I was kind of irritated with her anyway; if she'd gone with PG and Erik and taken out Todd, she would have made the game even MORE interesting. What was she thinking, anyway?? It should have been clear to her that she was DEFINITELY #4 in that alliance without PG pointing it out to her; what did she think was going to happen when it was down to 4?? Then to top it off she gives Amanda that big sob story about how "this is it for her" and if she'd gone with PG and Erik she wouldn't have had to do that. So I was totally out of sympathy in that department by then.
I do have to say, tho I found Courtney highly abrasive (even more so than PG, who I actually DID like), she won my respect by the end. She's a "what you see is what you get" girl and THE MOUTH is part of that, and I respect that. Plus she made I think the best case for herself in front of the jury.
I would have voted for Amanda, tho. Deceptive? Yeah, so?? Like NO ONE who won Survivor ever has been before. She won a lot of points with me with her taking out James manuever, which I thought was one of the smartest things I'd ever seen. (Tho she was admittedly helped out by James' temporary stupidity with the idols). And if Denise hadn't waffled, I think she would have taken Todd out, too. I think Todd actually did play the best game, but those cocky self-satisfied smirks every time someone got voted out, plus his HIGHLY condescending speech to the jury, just really got on my nerves.
I must say tho, that I have never before seen three finalists who actually looked BETTER after being on "the island" for 39 days than they did in the studio!! Amanda looked OK, but looked so much prettier without the makeup; Courtney looked cute in China but trashy in the studio, and as for Todd -- in the studio, he looked like a hobbit who had run away from Middle Earth to join a New Wave band.
Overall, I have to rate this edition 2nd behind Pearl Islands, and just ahead of Australia, out of the ones I've seen from start to finish. Definitely one of the best -- and if they'd taken Todd out earlier, it could have been even better.