Switching coaches: Yay or nay? | Golden Skate

Switching coaches: Yay or nay?

celiabiche

Clockwise skaters superfan
On the Ice
Joined
Jun 9, 2025
United-States
Hello! I have been considering switching coaches for a few weeks now and have been encouraged to by a friend but I would like some external opinions if possible! I have only been skating for about a year and 3 months and I started working with my current coach last August. She is one of the younger coaches at the rink and is much cheaper than some of the more experienced ones. I definitely consider her a friend at the rink as well as my coach but recently I feel that her teaching has become more repetitive and bland. Nothing wrong with repetition, I understand that skaters always need reminders, even for the little things, but it's beginning to feel almost lazy? Our lessons are 45 minutes each and the first 15 minutes is typically her chatting and catching me up, which I don't mind at times but I'm paying her for the full 45 minutes which feels like a waste if she isn't even teaching for part of that time. She also cancels often. It's starting to feel like every other week I get a text that she's either sick or having car problems or accidentally booked someone else for our session. She also will show up 2–5 minutes late and not even mention it which isn't the worst thing in the world but I make it a point to show up as promptly as possible, the only time I was ever late to a lesson was when my mom had unknowingly broken her foot and struggled to drive me. There are pros to her though! Her prices are some of the cheapest at the rink which is convenient and she is an amazinggg spinner and always gives me super helpful corrections with spins, more so than any other coach has. She deals in showcase more than technical which is also what I am aiming to do so in that aspect she's extremely helpful. I just feel that if I switch, I will also be losing a friend, especially since I've been working with her for so long now. She has talked to me about some coaches 'stealing' her students before and if I switch I don't want her to feel like I'm betraying her. That sounds a bit dramatic lol but I really want to maintain good relations with all of the coaches and skaters here since it's not like I can just switch rinks the minute things start to get a bit awkward.lmk if anyone has any advice </3
 
Hello! I have been considering switching coaches for a few weeks now and have been encouraged to by a friend but I would like some external opinions if possible! I have only been skating for about a year and 3 months and I started working with my current coach last August. She is one of the younger coaches at the rink and is much cheaper than some of the more experienced ones. I definitely consider her a friend at the rink as well as my coach but recently I feel that her teaching has become more repetitive and bland. Nothing wrong with repetition, I understand that skaters always need reminders, even for the little things, but it's beginning to feel almost lazy? Our lessons are 45 minutes each and the first 15 minutes is typically her chatting and catching me up, which I don't mind at times but I'm paying her for the full 45 minutes which feels like a waste if she isn't even teaching for part of that time. She also cancels often. It's starting to feel like every other week I get a text that she's either sick or having car problems or accidentally booked someone else for our session. She also will show up 2–5 minutes late and not even mention it which isn't the worst thing in the world but I make it a point to show up as promptly as possible, the only time I was ever late to a lesson was when my mom had unknowingly broken her foot and struggled to drive me. There are pros to her though! Her prices are some of the cheapest at the rink which is convenient and she is an amazinggg spinner and always gives me super helpful corrections with spins, more so than any other coach has. She deals in showcase more than technical which is also what I am aiming to do so in that aspect she's extremely helpful. I just feel that if I switch, I will also be losing a friend, especially since I've been working with her for so long now. She has talked to me about some coaches 'stealing' her students before and if I switch I don't want her to feel like I'm betraying her. That sounds a bit dramatic lol but I really want to maintain good relations with all of the coaches and skaters here since it's not like I can just switch rinks the minute things start to get a bit awkward.lmk if anyone has any advice </3
Our system in Canada is somewhat different, the coaches being employees of clubs, not the rink, and having to first go through a training process to be certified where they're apprentices to a senior coach and supervised by them, but is it possible for you to temporarily overlap and afford lessons with two coaches at your rink? To approach a coach with a better work ethic and say something like you'd really like to learn, say, basic jumps or a particular spin, but that your current coach is having scheduling problems. "Do you have the time to give me some lessons the weeks that she's not here?" Then either your current young coach will smarten up if she learns you're working with someone else when she's not there, or she'll slacken off even more and eventually disappear. If she confronts you about this, you (or your mother) can just say, "Well, you weren't here but I was. I'm serious about wanting to learn more, and Coach X had the time, so....." and maybe she'll get the picture why her pupils are deserting her (which is probably what's happening, not that other coaches are stealing them away).

Our club once took on a recently-retired Canadian ice dance champion, 7th in the world, when he retired and began certifying under the supervision of our head dance coach. I booked lessons with him hoping to pick up some ideas for free dance programs since I knew he and his partner had done a lot of their own choreography. But he had the attitude that he was doing his pupils a favour by coaching them, and a lot of his lesson time was spent just reminiscing about his experiences skating in Worlds and the Olympics. Interesting, but not what I was paying him to do. So I just went to his mentor and she switched the several adult pupils who reported the same problem with him to other fully certified coaches, and told him why. He was miffed, but to his credit he did smarten up and start to actually teach. I never went back to him for lessons, but we did become friends off the ice.

Not the same situation as yours, or the same system of finding the right coach, but just letting you know that this happens often with young coaches starting out. There's no reason why you (or your parents) should waste money on lessons that aren't happening. Skating is an expensive enough sport as it is! As long as you're polite and discreet about approaching other coaches and don't criticize her or gossip about her to others, it's your right to switch to a coach who will give you your money's worth. Hopefully also your current coach will have the maturity to learn a lesson herself, to work on her attitude and become a better coach.
 
I had a lot of different coaches, who advocated very different techniques. It can be confusing.

Have you thought about talking to your current coach about what you would like to change? It might not fix everything, but if you explain you want to spend time on new skills, maybe that will help.
 
I would be upfront with her and have a conversation with her telling her what you need and expect and if its realistic to continue having a coach student relationship. If she knows your needs coming from you she can maybe adjust her explanations or show you physically hands on etc. If you see things improving then that would be great but if not then I think you will know your answer. Also mention the professionalism of a coach when you are a paying student. Its ok to be friends as well but both of you need to be on the same page of that side of the relationship aswell.
 
Hi. This is a really tough situation. Your best bet here might be speaking to the supervising or head coach of the figure skating program, b/c I don't think your current coach has the maturity to handle being told one would like to find another coach, and has proven this by what she has shared with you in the past.

I wish you luck.
 
Not that I want to speculate, but I wonder if the "stolen students" also had similar issues you're having and they + parents transitioned to other more reliable coaches 🤔

Also, I find that when I come to my lessons with exactly what I want to work that day all the chit-chat disappears. You might benefit from being more proactive with your skating lessons if that's allowed at this stage. Though I'd love it if more coaches didn't have to be reminded that we're here to work, and maybe once in a blue moon talk about their equine prancing competitions 🙃
 
follow up to this thread I posted many months ago now—
I officially did it! It’s been about 2 weeks now since I officially switched and this past week I had my first lesson with my new coach. So far things have been going smoothly, still on good terms with the past coach (I think) BUT I have heard talk that she believes my new coach “stole me”. So less blame on me, more so on my new coach which isn’t great but I’m hoping with a little bit of time things will smoothen out
 
It is conceivable your old coach should start to wonder why she loses students to other coaches. :)

(Though, BTW, it is sometimes hard for someone to learn why if they don't get any feedback.)

OTOH, it isn't unusual for relatively inexperienced or low level coaches to lose students, especially good students, to more experienced and higher level coaches. Plus, it's very common for students to find that their personal learning style meshes better with a different coach's teaching style. Hopefully she will learn to take that in stride, and not take it as a personal affront.
 
follow up to this thread I posted many months ago now—
I officially did it! It’s been about 2 weeks now since I officially switched and this past week I had my first lesson with my new coach. So far things have been going smoothly, still on good terms with the past coach (I think) BUT I have heard talk that she believes my new coach “stole me”. So less blame on me, more so on my new coach which isn’t great but I’m hoping with a little bit of time things will smoothen out
I'm glad that you finally switched coaches and things are going well with the new one. Don't worry about the old coach, let her think what she will, we established early on in this thread that she wasn't mature enough to take these things in stride and not have to lay the blame somewhere other than herself.

Enjoy learning from your new coach! :biggrin:
 
It is likely that some of the readers of this forum are inexperienced coaches - including coaches who wish to lose fewer students to other coaches.

A thread like this one needn't just be useful to the o.p. and other students who consider switching. It could also be a lesson to such coaches on the value of maintaining good relations with everyone they can.

If students are aware that a coach resents other coaches, other coaches probably are too. Which means students and other coaches are less likely to recommend that coach. It could also influence decisions on whether one is allowed to teach.

And showing up promptly and reliably does matter.

I also think it worthwhile to elicit feedback from students on what and how one is teaching. That's an important part of adapting to students' goals and learning styles. Which, IMO, is one of the hallmarks of a great teacher of any subject - not just skating.
 
I had a lot of different coaches, who advocated very different techniques. It can be confusing.

I employ a few different coaches between myself, my spouse, and five children. Having one coach for everybody just isn't feasible due to scheduling constraints. There's definitely a divide amongst the coaches at my rink. Sometimes they are strongly opposed to each other's methods on certain things. It's an even bigger problem when my kids go to LTS where they have random coaches. Sometimes the LTS coach has said to them that they don't care what they're doing in their private lessons or even in a previous LTS class, they need to do it that particular coach's way in the LTS class. Then they won't be able to something well that they can normally do just fine, and won't progress through the LTS classes as quickly. It's worked out well enough though since there's different coaches all the time. It's relieving now that the older ones have passed all the Basic levels - I basically just wanted them to get past those so that they are welcome on freestyle sessions. Honestly LTS is a bit of a chaotic mess, haha. But it's good for working through all the basic skills and getting exposure to many different coaches.

It is likely that some of the readers of this forum are inexperienced coaches - including coaches who wish to lose fewer students to other coaches.

A thread like this one needn't just be useful to the o.p. and other students who consider switching. It could also be a lesson to such coaches on the value of maintaining good relations with everyone they can.

If students are aware that a coach resents other coaches, other coaches probably are too. Which means students and other coaches are less likely to recommend that coach. It could also influence decisions on whether one is allowed to teach.

And showing up promptly and reliably does matter.

I also think it worthwhile to elicit feedback from students on what and how one is teaching. That's an important part of adapting to students' goals and learning styles. Which, IMO, is one of the hallmarks of a great teacher of any subject - not just skating.
My last coach changed the schedule once without telling me - I was there for my lesson and he was coaching someone else when it was my time, ignoring me when I'd try to make eye contact and focusing on the student instead (I didn't want to outright interrupt). I was upset about it because I felt not taken seriously so I ended up taking a break for a while to just sit down, then get a text from him a half hour later asking where I am. When I talked to him he said he had to change the time to later but forgot to tell me. Other times he told me the day of the lesson, when seeing me at the rink, that he had something else to do so needed to cancel. If he did let me know he needed to cancel by text in advance, it was very shortly before the lesson. I understand needing to cancel sometimes but letting people know in advance if at all possible is preferred, certainly before the student has come to the rink expecting a lesson. I no longer have that coach and don't want to work with him again.

The resentfulness between coaches is frankly unprofessional. I don't always like all of my coworkers, but I'm not going to go talking bad about them or putting down their work behind their backs. It makes the coaching landscape difficult to navigate for students and parents. Of the many coaches at my rink, only a handful are willing to come to morning freestyle sessions when we have time to skate (or only will if we pay for a longer block of time than we'd prefer), many of those who are are already engaged with other students. We have to try to find ones that are available, can be reliable, provide worthwhile instruction, and have personalities that click with the students - having to worry about which coaches get along with other ones is an extra challenge we really don't need when paying a lot of money for the coaching time. Each student needs to have a primary coach whose specific instructions trump any secondary coaching, without resentment and contradictory statements from secondary coaches about that. Sometimes the most proven coaches are the worst about this, which is an unfortunate irony, since you both want to employ them thanks to their track record but at the same time don't want to because of the negative politics.

I haven't replaced my former coach yet, trying to take my time with making that decision. It's frustrating how difficult it is. It's hard to try out a coach and then leave them when problems come to light later - some coaches will blacklist skaters for that, and there's really only one rink that's viable for us to go to regularly. It's especially difficult when you have multiple skaters you're trying to coordinate and align coaching for.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top