The Greatest Of All Time | Page 6 | Golden Skate

The Greatest Of All Time

Not only were Mozart and Bach better, so was Haydn. :)

Edit: As for Plushenko, I think the reason that he does not get as much love as his haul of medals would justify, is that his on-ice personality was somewhat cool and distant.
I rather think it is today's political whirlwinds, to say no more.
 
God knows I am a huge fan of both Patrick and Nathan – as well as Javi and Shoma, to have the list of Yuzuru's main rivals complete – but none of them stands a chance against Yuzuru in terms of GOATness. Still can't decide between Yuzu and Plush, though.
The truth is I did not follow FS neither at Plushenko's peak, nor at Patrick's peak. I obviously knew then who Plushenko was. Never heard of Patrick Chan. And I do not mean to be mean. Just where I live his name did not make it outside the narrow FS fandom. Plushenko's name did. So did Yuzuru's.
 
Last edited:
Basketball in the U.S. is currently at a crossroads. The NBA logo for decades was a silhouuette of Jerry West, a star from the 1960s.


They have talked about adopting a new logo for years, but they didn't want to hurt West's feelings, who was still involved in basketball after his playinmg days were over. Mr. West passed away last month at age 86. Hoo, boy, here we go! The general consensus is that the new logo should be some version of the advertising logo of "Air Jrodans" (a brand of Nike basketball shoe endorsed by Michael.) :rock:

I very much doubt that the ISU or other officials who use Yuzu's image are in the least bit concerned about that :devil: but to be fair they have the rights to the images and no one can deny he is beautiful.....
The point is Yuzuru's image is used for logos which are created ad hoc today, and for teasers of new season's competitions which are also newly compiled. It has nothing to do with what Mathman mentions. It is just a click bait, that's all.
 
I am not sure bringing this interview is out of context. In some ways, it just serves to show what some people say in this thread : there is no GOAT but there ia herd of them.
Maybe yes, maybe no, but this interview proves nothing of the sort in the matter of the GOAT seeking. The only thing it proves is that Yuzuru was a very polite kid although shy of speaking English.
 
Last edited:
I obviously knew then who Plushenko was.
To be fair, Plushenko not only won a whole lot, he appeared at Eurovision as set decoration for Russia's only winning entry in 2008: 64 million people watched that live. (This year 163 million watched Eurovision by the way, maybe some of the European feds should try angling to get their best as set decoration next year).
 
To be fair, Plushenko not only won a whole lot, he appeared at Eurovision as set decoration for Russia's only winning entry in 2008: 64 million people watched that live. (This year 163 million watched Eurovision by the way, maybe some of the European feds should try angling to get their best as set decoration next year).
I never watched Eurovision in my life. Surely, that was not the reason I heard of Plushenko. At his peak, he was just damn famous making it to the general news and being just one of those famous athletes in Europe.
 
Funny you ask about Yuzuru being respected back. At worlds in Montreal, a Japanese fan was speaking to Patrick, about Yuzuru and Patrick had the nicest words to say about Hanyu.
From the transcript posted above by another poster of what Patrick said in Montreal it seems he had nice words to say about Dai to whom he would rarely lose, if any time at all, not so many nice words about Yuzuru, so I have no idea what you're talking about. Here comes what I was talking about.
"I gave him that win today so that mine tastes better when it really matters" - is that what Patrick Chan famously said to the camera when he first lost GPF to a Japanese teen (meaning most probably coming Sochi OG)? More or less (as I am quoting from memory). His fans explain it was a joke. Obviously a very bad one.
Looking away and not finding it in yourself to clap your hands when your rival is decorated with the Olympic gold and you just got your silver is generally considered a bad taste if not the bad sport. Ever watched Sochi medal ceremony by chance and how Patrick, 23, behaved there?
Here you go (a vid for a vid).

And that pathetic photo he posted on his Instagram to show how "wounded" he was by Yuzuru at the Sochi Olympic gala but offering no words of explanation that the accident was not the OGM's fault, which he obviously must have been aware of.
My question about respect and whether it was mutual was not out of nowhere.
I did not follow FS when Patrick Chan was at his peak. I first saw him when he was losing to Yuzuru Hanyu. Unlike so many posters here, I have no sentimental memories of him to cherish and justify. To me, he'was just a bad sport, no matter how great his skating skills.
 
Last edited:
We seem to have gotten off the topic here, Patrick Chan saying nice or nasty things about his competition, Patrick Chan being a good or bad sport (and the same goes for everyone else) does not make him a GOAT. The leading lights, the absolute geniuses for the ages in many fields have sometimes been unpleasant people and said (and did) unpleasant things. It's harder to get away with it now, because the acoustics (and the audience reaction) are different. On the other hand, some of the geniuses have been perfectly lovely people. That doesn't make them more leading light than the rotters.

What could be looked at is GOATs on a national level: is Chan that for Canadian men, or is Browning? Kwan would take the US women, Yuzu Japan, Yuna Kim definitely Korea... Russian women, god only knows.
 
We seem to have gotten off the topic here, Patrick Chan saying nice or nasty things about his competition, Patrick Chan being a good or bad sport (and the same goes for everyone else) does not make him a GOAT. The leading lights, the absolute geniuses for the ages in many fields have sometimes been unpleasant people and said (and did) unpleasant things. It's harder to get away with it now, because the acoustics (and the audience reaction) are different.

What could be looked at is GOATs on a national level: is Chan that for Canadian men, or is Browning? Kwan would take the US women, Yuzu Japan, Yuna Kim definitely Korea... Russian women, god only knows.
Sorry, I disagree.I think certain kind of behaviour disqualifies you as a GOAT. You cannot be that bad a sport and claim to be the greatest of all time.
 
Okay I made a satire list here's a real one

Mens: Controversial but Nathan Chen. Absolutely Nathan Chen.
Womens: I'm going to have to say Yuna Kim. She's one of the few women to ever put out a skate that was actually as close to perfect as you can reasonably get. Even skates that are clean tend to have have errors. Not Yuna's best skates, her best skates were actually (nearly) perfect. Yuna is not the kind of skater I enjoy watching, but she is undeniably the GOAT for me.
Ice Dance: Papadakis/Cizeron. I know everyone wants to say Tessa and Scott. But as an ice dancer I really appreciate how hard a level 4 step sequence is and just how often P/C were able to do it compared to their competition. And don't get me started on the one foot turn sequence. P/C consistently did a clean bracket. That is actually insane.
 
From the transcript posted above by another poster of what Patrick said in Montreal it seems he had nice words to say about Dai to whom he would rarely lose, if any time at all, not so many nice words about Yuzuru,...
The part about who he beat more often was awkward, I agree. But it is natural to look up to a slightly older performer (Daisuke) whose skating Patrick had consciously emulated, more so than to he new kid on the block.

In general I do not hold any grudge against what skaters say in improptu and unrehearsed interviews. Sasha Cohen once blurted out about Michelle Kwan, "Isn't she EVER going to retire?!"
 
Last edited:
The part about who he beat more often was awkward, I agree. But it is natural to look up to a slightly older performer (Daisuke) whose skating Patrick had consciously emulated, more so than tto he new kid on the block.

In general I do not hold any grudge against what skaters say in improptu and unrehearsed interviews. Sasha Cohen one blurted out about Michellel Kwan, "Isn't she EVER going to retire?!"
I do. So we differ.. Sorry, Mathman. I mean it.
 
Okay I made a satire list here's a real one

Mens: Controversial but Nathan Chen. Absolutely Nathan Chen.
Not that controversial to me. Nathan's skating is just so precisely executed. He always looks good on the ice, no matter from where you are looking. He had interesting programs and of course, very steady and high level technical content. To me, he is also one of the very balanced skaters. Some see him more like a quadster, I disagree... but eh, as you said, Controversial :)
 
Well, I absolutely don't get the love for Patrick Chan, and no matter what Tracy Wilson or anyone else said, there were many skaters before him who balanced the artistic and the technical. I do t get it.

But there are many people who love him, so again, personal opinion.

I also agree that Plushenko at the height of his fame was more famous than Patrick Chan, at least in Europe.
 
It raises - at least to me - an interesting question of how displays of arrogance and/or poor sportsmanship does affect the general or historic view of a skater's actual claim to greatness (please note the word general, I do not mean specific fans or fan groups). I know I said that for me it shouldn't (although I do not lay claim to being objective, especially when it's someone I don't like anyway) but I'm thinking more of 'the public', maybe casual fans, and in different countries.

Besides Chan, the cases I can think of straight off are Plushenko (who seems to have gotten away with it for quite a long time), Surya Bonaly, Kerrigan (those remarks about the girl who beat her) and Trusova's outburst at the Olympics (because I am damn sure I read more criticisms of her skating technique and 'what does she expect' after that than before). Oh, and Malinin's dig at gay skaters for which he apparently received pr training. I'm sure there are others but did the criticism of behaviour taint the memory of performance in some of these? It's something that seems to vary from sport to sport, of course.

And furthermore with Kerrigan especially, if she had won the Olympic medal, providing a happy ending to the whole saga and no chance to be overheard being catty in defeat, would she now be remembered by at least some of the public as one of the greats rather than a featured player in a hit movie about someone else?
 
Last edited:
Well, I absolutely don't get the love for Patrick Chan, and no matter what Tracy Wilson or anyone else said, there were many skaters before him who balanced the artistic and the technical. I do t get it.
Yes there were. But what Patrick did was to bring the stable two quad long and the skating skills. Skaters like Jeff Buttle, Daisuke Takahashi and Stéphane Lambiel all had the great skating skills but they lacked stability with one of the main jumps (quad or 3A). When Patrick started winning his title, it was after 2 medals at worlds but without quads. The year he brought in the quads and won his first title, there was a big reaction within the skating world and commentators about the arrival, of a skater who could do it all. That's what Tracy Wilson (and many other commentators) have often referred to. It doesn't remove anything to anyone else who skated before or after. It's just a moment in time where Patrick had an edge (pun intended) on his competitors. What Yuzuru and Javier brought in was the stable two different quads. I am guessing I don't need to bring up everyone else's contribution. A lot of skaters this final years have raised the technical bar. It's obvious I am a Chan fan. I am not hiding it. At this point, I don't find many skaters to have a complete balance, so it does mean something important to me, that Patrick was recognized for that... I understand that many fans may have a different perception but i am generously sharing mine ;)
But there are many people who love him, so again, personal opinion.

I also agree that Plushenko at the height of his fame was more famous than Patrick Chan, at least in Europe.
I am not surprised that Plushenko was more famous in Europe.. Don't forget that Europeans have Euros which is a very important competition for skaters as opposed to 4CC. It certainly helps.
 
Not only were Mozart and Bach better, so was Haydn. :)

Edit: As for Plushenko, I think the reason that he does not get as much love as his haul of medals would justify, is that his on-ice personality was somewhat cool and distant.
Totally, Plushenko was brilliant skater but somehow I couldn't feel the link with him, that I felt with skaters like Stanick Jeannette or Kevin van der Perren, who both were obviously less brilliant technically but you could see they skate because they like it. I think it's the same way some people prefered joyful Candeloro over focused Stojko, although Stojko could be like Candeloro, each time he succeeded in quadcombo, you could see how his joy of skating was immediately visible.
 
We seem to have gotten off the topic here, Patrick Chan saying nice or nasty things about his competition, Patrick Chan being a good or bad sport (and the same goes for everyone else) does not make him a GOAT. The leading lights, the absolute geniuses for the ages in many fields have sometimes been unpleasant people and said (and did) unpleasant things. It's harder to get away with it now, because the acoustics (and the audience reaction) are different. On the other hand, some of the geniuses have been perfectly lovely people. That doesn't make them more leading light than the rotters.

What could be looked at is GOATs on a national level: is Chan that for Canadian men, or is Browning? Kwan would take the US women, Yuzu Japan, Yuna Kim definitely Korea... Russian women, god only knows.
Butyrskaya :wink:
 
The truth is I did not follow FS neither at Plushenko's peak, nor at Patrick's peak. I obviously knew then who Plushenko was. Never heard of Patrick Chan. And I do not mean to be mean. Just where I live his name did not make it outside the narrow FS fandom. Plushenko's name did. So did Yuzuru's.
When Patrick was at his peak I took a break from fs but still heard about him. I watched fs during Plushenko's logng career, yet I found almost every skater from top 10 at this time more intersting than Plushenko.
 
Back
Top