Your Gold, Silver, and Bronze Programs 2.0

[Izabela]

In the spirit and continuation of this thread, which programs from the last quad (2015-2018) will you award Gold, Silver, and Bronze from each category and discipline?

The categories are (to quote):

The categories are:
Men's SP
Men's FS
Ladies' SP
Ladies' FS
Pairs SP
Pairs FS
Dance SD
Dance FD

As with the previous version, Gold will earn 3 points, Silver 2 points, and Bronze 1 point. Again, no ties please! If you don't rank them I will just split 3 points to half (or how many programs you put there without ranking). You also don't have to fill in all categories. And make this fun. If you don't agree with other people's ranking, please don't ruin the thread!

So how will you rank them?

(I'm gonna put the tabulated results here in the OP too so people could easily check which programs are winning lol).

Current Rankings:

Men SP

1. GOLD - Yuzuru Hanyu - Chopin Ballade (40 Points)
2. SILVER - Javier Fernandez - Malaguena (19 Points)

3. BRONZE - Patrick Chan - Beatles Medley (17 Points)
Yuzuru Hanyu - Let's Go Crazy (17 Points)

Men's FS

1. GOLD - Yuzuru Hanyu - Seimei (53 Points) (THE ULTIMATE CROWD FAVORITE!)
2. SILVER - Patrick Chan - Chopin Medley (16 Points)
3. BRONZE - Javier Fernandez - Man of La Mancha (13 Points)


Ladies' SP

1. GOLD - Kaetlyn Osmond - Sous Le Ciel De Paris (42.5 Points)
2. SILVER - Carolina Kostner - Ne me Quitte Pas (31 Points)
3. BRONZE - Satoko Miyahara - Sayuri's Theme (26 Points)

Ladies' FS

1. GOLD - Evgenia Medvedeva - Anna Karenina (24 Points)Kaetlyn Osmond -
2. SILVER - Wakaba Higuchi - Skyfall (23 Points)
3. BRONZE - Black Swan (21 Points)

Pairs SP

1. GOLD - Sui Weijing/Han Cong - Blues for Klook (28 Points)
2. SILVER - Sui Weijing/Han Cong - Spanish Romance (15 Points)
3. BRONZE - A. Savchenko / B. Massot - That Man (14 Points)

Pairs FS

1. GOLD - A. Savchenko/B. Massot - La Terre Vue Du Ciel (41 Points)
2. SILVER - Sui Weijing/Han Cong - Bridge Over Troubled Water (22 Points)
3. BRONZE - M. Duhamel/E. Radforrd - Hometown Glory (14 Points)


Dance SD

1. GOLD - T. Virtue/S. Moir - Kiss (45 Points) (A CROWD FAVORITE!!)
2. SILVER - T. Virtue/S. Moir - Hotel California (13 Points)
3. BRONZE - P. Gilles/P. Poirier - Disco Inferno (12 Points)

Dance FD

1. GOLD - T. Virtue / S. Moir - Moulin Rouge! (35 Points)
2. SILVER - G. Papadakis/G. Cizeron - To Build A Home (23 Points)
3. BRONZE - M. Shibutani/A. Shibutani - Fix You (17 Points)

 

[chopinskate]

Pairs SP:

1. S/H Blues for Klook 2017 W: Despite the flawed synchronicity with the SBS spin.

 

[IndiaP12]

Idk how to do this [emoji23] I’m dumb

 

[chopinskate]

Just watch a lot of routines and form opinions.

 

[Izabela]

Idk how to do this [emoji23] I’m dumb

As long as you watched programs between 2015-2018, and just rank them (we're not looking for the most objective post here), which programs are you gonna give Gold, Silver or Bronze?

 

[chillgil]

id give the mens sp gold to yuzuru hanyu's ballade
i think its THE perfect program

 

[IndiaP12]

As long as you watched programs between 2015-2018, and just rank them (we're not looking for the most objective post here), which programs are you gonna give Gold, Silver or Bronze?

Oh ok thank you I thought so

 

[yume]

Men SP
Gold: Yuzu Ballade
Silver: Javier Fernandez malaguena
Bronze: Shoma Uno legends

Men FS
Gold: Yuzu Seimei
Silver: Patrick Chan Chopin medley
Bronze: Shoma Uno Loco

Ladies SP
Gold: Satoko Miyahara Sayuri
Silver: Zijun Li claire de lune
Bronze: Kaetlyn Osmond Edith piaf

Ladies FS
Gold: Mao Asada danza del fuego
Silver: Wakaba skyfall
Bronze: Carolina Kostner Nisi dominus

Pairs SP
Gold: Sui/Han blues for klook
Silver: Sui/Han Spanish romance
Bronze: Stolbova/Klimov i put a spell on you

Pairs FS
Gold: Stolbova/Klimov
man and the shadow
Silver: Sui/Han Bridge over troubled water
Bronze: Savchenko/Massot De la terre vue du ciel

Dance SD
Gold: Virtue/Moir Prince
Silver: Stepanova/Bukin Hip pop SD
Bronze: Gilles/Poirier Disco SD

Dance FD
Gold: Papadakis/Cizeron to build a home
Silver: Shibutani fix you
Bronze: Muramoto/Reed Ryuichi Sakamoto medley

 

[IndiaP12]

Just watch a lot of routines and form opinions.

I’ve watched many routines and have a lot of opinions, I just wasn’t sure exactly how to play hahahah

 

[geige]

Ladies SP:
1. Satoko Miyahara Memoirs of a Geisha
2. Mao Asada Fire Dance
3. Karen Chen On Golden Pond

Ladies FS:
1. Satoko Miyahara Madame Butterfly
2. Mao Asada Madame Butterfly
3. Ashley Wagner Moulin Rouge

so hard (

 

[Caliph2002]

Patrick Chan-Mack the Knife
Yuzuru Hanyu-Ballade
Shoma Uno-Violin Fantasy
Honourable Mentions: Shoma Uno Legends

Yuzuru Hanyu-Seimei
Patrick Chan-Chopin
Mikhail Kolyada-Nightmare before Christmas
Honourable Mentions: Javier Fernandez Guys and Dolls; Shoma Uno Turandot, Un poco loco; Misha Ge Meditation

Mao Asada-Bei mir
Ashley Wagner-Hip Hip Chin Chin
Kaetlyn Osmond-Edith Piaf
Honourable Mention: Evgenia Medvedeva Melodies of the White Nights, Satoko Miyahara Sayuri

Mao Asada-Madama Butterfly
Polina Edmunds-Gone with the Wind
Kaetlyn Osmond-Black Swan
Honourable Mentions: Evgenia Medvedeva Rene Aubry, Mao Asada Ritual Fire Dance

Sui/Han Blues
Volosozhar/Trankov Bollywood
Sui/Han Hallelujah
Honourable Mentions: Sui/Han Spanish Romance, Savchenko/Massot That Man

Savchenko/Massot La Terre Vue de Ciel
Savchenko/Massot Lighthouse
Sui/Han Bridge over Troubled Water
Honourable Mentions: Stolbova/Klimov Man and Shadow, Sui/Han Samson and Delilah, Volosozhar/Trankov Dracula

Virtue/Moir Prince
Weaver/Poje Paso Doble
Papadakis/Cizeron Paso Doble

Papadakis/Cizeron Build a Home
Papadakis/Cizeron Stillness
Papadakis/Cizeron Mozart Piano Concerto 23

 

[IndiaP12]

Ladies SP:
1. Alina Zagitova Black Swan
2. Carolina Kostner Ne Me Quitte Pas (I hope that’s spelt right)
3. Evgenia Medvedeva Nocturne (partly because I just love the music [emoji23])

Ladies FS:
1. Alina Zagitova Don Quixote [emoji7]
2. Evgenia Medvedeva Anna Karenina
3. Satoko Miyahara Madame Butterfly

Yes they are all 2017/18 season cause it’s the season I was most present for

Alina’s not top because I’m biased as she’s the Olympic champion, it’s because I absolutely LOVED her programs from this season and how could you not put them top

 

[IndiaP12]

I’ll do honourable mentions too:

Ladies SP:

Bradie Tennell Taegugki

Ladies FS:

I can’t choose but probably Kaetlyn’s Black Swan or Zhenya’s Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close

 

[mrrice]

Men...Patrick Chan's Blackbird......

Ladies...Another shoutout for Karen's On Golden Pond.

Ladies.... Kaetlyn's Edith Piaf.

 

[Skater Boy]

In the spirit and continuation of this thread, which programs from the last quad (2015-2018) will you award Gold, Silver, and Bronze from each category and discipline?

The categories are (to quote):



As with the previous version, Gold will earn 3 points, Silver 2 points, and Bronze 1 point. Again, no ties please! You also don't have to fill in all categories. And make this fun. If you don't agree with other people's ranking, please don't ruin the thread!

So how will you rank them?

(I'm gonna put the tabulated results here in the OP too so people could easily check which programs are winning lol).

Are you talking actually performed program or the actual design program. Because some programs may be the best or very good but were not skated well if that makes sense? Also, what some may deem the best skated program may not be the most difficult program or highest scoring because say the jumps weren't as hard.

 

[chopinskate]

Just consider the overall package, I'd say.

 

[lovaticcanada]

Men SP
1. Patrick Chan Mack the Knife
2. Javier Fernandez Malagueña
3. Yuzuru Hanyu Let's Go Crazy

Men FS
1. Patrick Chan Chopin
2. Javier Fernandez Guys and Dolls
3. Yuzuru Hanyu Hope and Legacy

Ladies SP
1. Kaetlyn Osmond Edith Piaf
2. Evgenia Medvedeva River Flows in You
3. Marin Honda The Giving

Ladies FS
1. Kaetlyn Osmond Black Swan
2. Evgenia Medvedeva Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close
3. Marin Honda Beetlejuice

Pairs SP
1. Sui/Han Spanish Romance
2. Savchenko/Massot That Man
3. Duhamel/Radford With or Without You

Pairs FS
1. Savchenko/Massot La terre vue du ciel
2. Sui/Han Bridge over Troubled Water
3. Duhamel/Radford Hometown Glory

Dance SD
1. Virtue/Moir Prince
2. Virtue/Moir Rhumba
3. Gilles/Poirier Disco

Dance FD
1. Virtue/Moir Latch
2. Virtue/Moir Moulin Rouge
3. Shibutani Fix You

 

[Izabela]

Are you talking actually performed program or the actual design program. Because some programs may be the best or very good but were not skated well if that makes sense? Also, what some may deem the best skated program may not be the most difficult program or highest scoring because say the jumps weren't as hard.

I say don't think too much about it, if you prefer scoring them on the actual performed program, you could do so. If it's about design, you could also do so. It's just a matter of how you want to score them depending on your mileage. Their actual scores should not also matter. If you look at the previous thread on this, most folks just scored based on their preferences. If you think a program with less difficult jumps is still much better overall, you can award that. Again, this is supposed to be just lighthearted and fun.

ETA: Current Rankings:


Men SP

1. GOLD - Patrick Chan - Mack The Knife (6.0 Points)
2. SILVER - Yuzuru Hanyu - Chopin Ballade (5.0 Points)
3. BRONZE - Javier Fernandez - Malaguena (4.0 Points)

Men's FS

1. GOLD - Yuzuru Hanyu - Seimei (6.0 Points)
Patrick Chan - Chopin Medley (6.0 Points)
2. SILVER - Javier Fernandez - Guys and Dolls (2.0 Points)
3. BRONZE - Shoma Uno - Loco (1.0 Point)
Mikhail Kolyada - Nightmare Before Christmas (1.0 Point)
Yuzuru Hanyu - Hope and Legacy (1.0 Point)

Ladies' SP

1. GOLD - Kaetlyn Osmond - Sous Le Ciel De Paris (6.5 Points)
2. SILVER - Satoko Miyahara - Mayuri's Theme (6.0 Points)
3. BRONZE - Mao Asada - Ritual Fire Dance (SP) (3.0 Points)
Mao Asada - Bei Mir Bistu Shein (3.0 Points)
Alina Zagitova - Black Swan (3.0 Points)
Bradie Tennell - Taegukgi (3.0 Points)


Ladies' FS

1. GOLD - Kaetlyn Osmond - Black Swan (5.5 Points)
2. SILVER - Mao Asada - Madame Butterfly (5.0 Points)
3. BRONZE - Satoko Miyahara - Madame Butterfly (4.0 Points)

Pairs SP

1. GOLD - Sui Weijing/Han Cong - Blues for Klook (9.0 Points)
2. SILVER - Sui Weijing/Han Cong - Spanish Romance (5.0 Points)
3. BRONZE - A. Savchenko / B. Massot - That Man (2.0 Points)
T. Volozozhar/M. Trankov - Nagada Sang Dhol (2.0 Points)

Pairs FS

1. GOLD - A. Savchenko/B. Massot - La Terre Vue Du Ciel (7.0 Points)
2. SILVER - Sui Weijing/Han Cong - Bridge Over Troubled Water (5.0 Points)
3. BRONZE - K.A. Stolbova/F. Klimov - Man and Shadow (3.0 Points)


Dance SD

1. GOLD - T. Virtue/S. Moir - Kiss (9.0 Points)
2. SILVER - T. Virtue/S. Moir - Hotel California (2.0 Points)
A. Stepanova /I. Bukin - At Last (2.0 Points)
K. Weaver/A. Poje - La Virgen de La Macarena (2.0 Points)
3. BRONZE - P. Gilles/P. Poirier - Oh What A Night For Dancing (1.0 Point)
P. Gilles/P. Poirier - Disco Inferno (1.0 Point)
G. Papadakis / G. Cizeron - Escobilla (1.0 Point)

Dance FD

1. GOLD - G. Papadakis/G. Cizeron - To Build A Home (6.0 Points)
2. SILVER - T. Virtue / S. Moir - Latch (3.0 Points)
M. Shibutani/A. Shibutani - Fix You (3.0 Points)
3. BRONZE - T. Virtue / S. Moir - Moulin Rouge (2.0 Points)
G. Papadakis/G. Cizeron - Stillness (2.0 Points)

 

[chopinskate]

Ladies SP:
1. Karen Chen: On Golden Pond, 2017 US Nationals -- What an utter delight to see the musical interpretation, the attention to detail, and the poise.

 

[Anyasnake]

This is SO hard not to pick 1 skater/team for the whole podium but diversity so I'm doing my best !

Men SP

Gold : Yuzuru Hanyu Chopin
Silver : Patrick Chan Dust in the wind
Bronze : Javier Fernandez Black Betty

Men FS

Gold : Yuzuru Hanyu Seimei
Silver : Javier Fernandez Guys and Dolls
Bronze : Shoma Uno Turandot

Ladies SP : (This is SO difficult, Ladies' game is ON)

Gold : Satoko Miyahara Mayuri's Theme
Silver : Carolina Kostner Ne me quitte pas
Bronze : Alina Zagitova Black Swan
(almost a tie with Kaetlyn, love her SP)

Ladies FS :

Gold : Kaori Sakamoto Amelie
Silver : Alina Zagitova Don Quixote
Bronze : Kaetlyn Osmond Black Swan

Pairs SP :

Gold : Sui/Han Spanish Romance
Silver : Savchenko/Massot That man
Bronze : Tarasova/Morozov Rachmaninov

Pairs FS :

Gold : Savchenko/Massot La Terre vu du ciel (tied with Lighthouse but I said I wouldn't pick the same team twice)
Silver : Sui/Han Bridge Over troubled water
Bronze : James/Cipres Sound of Silence

Dance SD : (this is quite difficult not to pick P/C or V/M several times...)

Gold : Papadakis/Cizeron Shape of You
Silver : Virtue/Moir Prince
Bronze : Hubbell/Donohue Latin

Dance FD :

Gold : Papadakis/Cizeron To Build a Home (tied with all the other FDs but I had to make a choice...)
Silver : Shibutani/Shibutani Fix You
Bronze : Hubbell Donohue Caught out in the Rain