- Joined
- Nov 22, 2009
Yeah, usually he does 4F but this time, not even a triple. He may be having some trouble with it, so left it out. I don't think he likes loops very much.
I get "he's not my cup of tea" or "not my style of skating" but I'm tired of comments that target his performance while he is clearly putting an effort. Can he do better? No doubt.No, it means he can perform better than he does. You are free to compare him with Hanyu or Uno or Takahashi. Or not.
He's a fine performer, but Vincent doesn't totally excel at anything, be it performance, clean jumps, spins, or skating skills. He's very very good at everything he does, but he just doesn't quite hit the mark on any of them to truly stand out. He had some really bad luck coming up in the US with Nathan right behind him to be the technical king and Jason as the PCS king, and hopefully he'll be able to develop his own niche in skating over time. And I do see some moments of a true, natural performer in both his short and free, so hopefully he'll grow that over this season and beyond.To all of you who keep saying "I feel nothing on his skate, he is souless..", like does he have to cry midway in the performance for you to feel something???? Geez...
We shouldn't forget that the USFS shouldn't have even been in this position to begin with, and that they were was also entirely Zhou's doing.And that, my friends, is why USFS put their trust in Vincent.
I think a lot of jumps were landed rather on q, than called as <. With totally clean 4 quads and 2 trixels his TES should have been well above 100.Looks like Shin Amano had a nibble on that.
I think he excels at his overall program performance when the timing is right and the universe aligns. Otherwise he wouldn't have won this competition. Not giving up, not letting yourself go down into oblivion, and coming back stronger after a bad season it's a merit on its own.He's a fine performer, but Vincent doesn't totally excel at anything, be it performance, clean jumps, spins, or skating skills. He's very very good at everything he does, but he just doesn't quite hit the mark on any of them to truly stand out. He had some really bad luck coming up in the US with Nathan right behind him to be the technical king and Jason as the PCS king, and hopefully he'll be able to develop his own niche in skating over time. And I do see some moments of a true, natural performer in both his short and free, so hopefully he'll grow that over this season and beyond.
Yeah, did you see all the Rotten Apples being lobbed at him recently ... even on polite Goldenskate forum?Calm down Vincent! This is not the REAL Olympics, just the qualifier...
Yeah, but I don't think I'm in a position to crucify him if he had lost Nebelhorn. As much as some people like to say the "but if Vincent doesn't qualify then what about my fav guy Jason..." quote, his skating life in not entitled to the federation or to the viewers. If he had lost here then the hate should be directed at USFS if they had picked him over Jason, not to a skater. Anyhow, I am just glad to watch him skate and overcome his challenges.We shouldn't forget that the USFS shouldn't have even been in this position to begin with, and that they were was also entirely Zhou's doing.
Making the free skate at Worlds should not be a difficult ask for a US National medallist.
As i've expected Judge NO. 3 judging his components tho
I think we should wait and see until we know the decisions. Like in January or whenever the olympic committees must make their choices? I wrote a bit about the Swedish situation in the European skating threadI know. But there are plenty of rumours that Sweden doesn't consider either of their singles skaters to mean the "development" exception.
Furthermore, there is precedent of Sweden doing so. To his older brother, in fact.
Finally, how do you suppose one should react to it?
Ah, that makes sense. Yeah, I'm nervous for them though.I think we should wait and see until we know the decisions. Like in January or whenever the olympic committees must make their choices? I wrote a bit about the Swedish situation in the European skating thread
Nothing ill meant to you.
I agree he's putting an effort. His choreography isn't bad either.I get "he's not my cup of tea" or "not my style of skating" but I'm tired of comments that target his performance while he is clearly putting an effort. Can he do better? No doubt.
I think his Short Program shows his artistic potential way more than his FS. His FS had a lot of unfinished movements and he could show more conviction in his poses and more tension in his hand gestures. This isn't a vehicle to win (unless there are disaster skates) but it keeps him in the mix (I mean, 43/88 PCS and a ton of quads which if weren't q would have had like about 10 points more GOE). He's definitely put himself in the medal conversation and obviously a competition like this gives him HUGE confidence. As others have said, he's not quite the level of artistry of the top guys, but he's putting in the effort. Same on his jumps too - there's more spring and he's holding his landings more. All his spins were level 4 too.He's a fine performer, but Vincent doesn't totally excel at anything, be it performance, clean jumps, spins, or skating skills. He's very very good at everything he does, but he just doesn't quite hit the mark on any of them to truly stand out. He had some really bad luck coming up in the US with Nathan right behind him to be the technical king and Jason as the PCS king, and hopefully he'll be able to develop his own niche in skating over time. And I do see some moments of a true, natural performer in both his short and free, so hopefully he'll grow that over this season and beyond.
sour grapes. And I loved your comment on the pbp you wrote for Vincent. "Job done." I suppose it was the best you could do.Looks like Shin Amano had a nibble on that.