As to not clog this ff up with a long essay about the history of redface, the history of colonialism in the Americas, the cultural subjugation and erasure of indigenous cultures including languages until late in the 20th century, and forcible cultural appropriation I suggest that anyone who wants to act respectfully go and do research. Lots of info out there.
Imagine your language was taken to the brink of extinction thanks to war, ethnic cleansing, and the residential school system. You are struggling to keep that language alive despite all that cultural and social destruction. Then a random cultural outsider feels it’s funny/cute to assign an “Indian” nickname to another cultural outsider who is engaging in redface. Casual misappropriation of words by someone who is not from societies still reeling from the effects of not being able to practice their own language, wear their traditional clothing and hairstyles, and engage in their own rituals and lifeways because they were supposed to be stamped out for good. That is why it cuts deep.
I love Shoma, but already it looks like from his costume and his music choice that he’s engaging in redface. I don’t doubt that he means well and is ignorant of the history of the Americas, but that doesn’t make the redface any more palatable. He comes from a position of privilege and power relative to indigenous individuals and hopefully he will learn from someone why this exhibition doesn’t look to be a great choice from that perspective. I see no reason why I can’t both admire his positive actions as well as note when he acts in a way that has negative impacts. I want him to learn and grow, and he is more than capable of doing so.
, but this whole situation doesn't come of as cultural appropriation to me. 
)
He is serious and respectful as well, this is why I am glad he has gone clubbing! Just enjoy I say! I don't care if he's clubbing in some black t-shirt/jeans/sneakers. (Perhaps he should!)
