I think i made my point very clear with the previous posts.
Now onto the accusations based on nothing:
1) I've never said other coaches have never had similar cases, i actually recall posting few weeks ago that Fedichkina should have continued cause she was very close to win Junior Worlds back in 2016, and her fate was basically determined by a couple of instances were judges unfairly scored her below Marin Honda (imo) and moving to Mishin was a bad idea for her.
I did say the other cases were never as big as the ones Sambo-70 and CSKA saw with skaters who were ready to compete and win medals at the most difficult competitions suddenly retire the year after. I stand by it, it's true.
2) As for Alisa Lozko, there is nothing else to add beyond what i've just said.
- It's NOT the same case as Alyona Kanysheva as Alisa Lozko has never won anything major in Juniors as like a JGPF medal, had only one season in JGP and didn't go well at all, scores were far lower, protocols show where are all her weaknesses and judges didn't pass on them. The skater had a lot to work on the technique still.
- You keep ignoring the fact that her retirement happened not because of Mishin wanting to get rid of her (as it's perhaps happening here, we don't know) but because she broke the rules by trying to switch coaches without consulting.
Alisa's situation is more similar to Daria Panenkova.
We can keep discussing about it when to me we should discuss more about Alyona Kanysheva.
Why a skater goes from one of the most talented in Russia in Ladies Singles in such a tough field - to -> retired from singles skating the year after.
I'd love to hear Panova's comments to that news, cause only 10-12 months ago Alena didn't look like a skater who wanted to retire at all.
Wow, that’s some fact twisting on the next level.
Enlighten me, which rules exactly did Alisa break? And better, provide me with a rule book and point which chapter and clause was the one that she did not follow through.
Ok, enough of this nonsense.
Where are you getting you info from?
According to Alisa, interview of whom I just re-read, she didn’t switch mid season, she tried to do it over the summer, because she did not progress under Mishin for a year and he also did not take her in his summer camp, whereas he took everyone else, but her. She was essentially left alone without coaches. According to Alisa herself.
(and plus even if she tried doing it mid season, switching mid-season is also allowed in some cases, again, FYI.)
And when she was forced to go back, again, not because she broke any rules, but because “Saint Petersburg did not want to lose a promising skater” (a quote from Alisa’s interview, she also says they weren’t provided an explanation), she was later dismissed by Mishin, who also went a step further and told other coaches not to take her.
If that does not count as “Mishin wanting to get rid of her, I don’t know what will”.
it’s baffling to me that you’re trying to turn everything upside down.
You never said “Other cases aren’t as big bla bla”, your literal words are:
“The only groups where you hear about early retirements of single skaters at this very top level are Sambo-70 and CSKA.”
Facts are, that’s not true. Those are not the “only groups” (and calling them groups is also wrong, those aren’t groups). Also, it depends on what you personally consider to be a top level apparently, not what’s actually is a top level? you have your own very special criteria, which is very convenient just to prove your point, right?
According to you, Alisa isn’t top level, because her jumping isn’t to your liking (although she had medals at jgps). Riiiight.
