Gracie has always had trouble with competition nerves. Not everyone is a natural competitor and age has only made that worse.
Mariah SP is terrible. I like Mariah but Adam doesn't know how to choreograph for her. She is has lovely glide across the ice and an effervescent quality. This program was choreographed for Adam not Mariah. It would highlight his strengths. It doesn't highlight Mariah's.
Alysa is such a stable competitor. I enjoyed her SP. Performances like this probably guarantee her a spot on the Olympic team.
In terms of pure effortless power and emotional, Amber wins. I don't like her program but , unlike Mariah, she sells the emotion well. I think the hard fall on the 3A in warmup shocked her a quite bit. But, she didn't pop anything. She went for everything. I think as the season progresses she will get this SP clean. She has learned to fight, she used to be a terrible competitor.
Audrey is lovely. But, I guess I don't respond to her skating like others do. She URs a lot. Even prior to injury, it was a problem. Hopefully, she will continue to improve.
Gabby has potential but her SP here was not strong. I think she needs more speed.