I had never watched her programs before, she was wonderful, she was the discovery of the year (at least for me), I wish she had finished fourth, but not higher, sorry: she did not have better jumps than AT and she was not more artistic than AS (in my opinion, there is still quite a huge gap, which is quite normal given the age gap). I have no problem with a junior skater being better than a senior skater, because "in souls nobly born valor does not depend upon age"... but I want the full package: jumps and artistry and grace and maturity. Unfortunately jumps have become the alpha and the omega of figure skating, so mature skaters have become comparable with young ones, if not inferior...