Reactions and criticism of judging by Network commentators - NBC, CBC, BBC, etc | Page 16 | Golden Skate

Reactions and criticism of judging by Network commentators - NBC, CBC, BBC, etc

Wrong on both counts. Nagasu edged Rochette in total Technical score, SP+FS, by about 1/2 a point. She lost to Rochette in PCS by about 12 points.

Well considering there is no valid case to say Nagasu deserved to be within a mere .5 of a point to Rochette on PCS in both programs (even if you argued giving her the same PCS in the LP she would still deserve lower in the short and behind overall), that just shows the decision of the 2010 bronze is a non starter. Even without an inflated PCS edge it still goes to Joannie.
 
Adelina's choreography and interpretation must have been extraordinary given the scores.
So please somebody kindly explain to me what she was interpreting and expressing. I'm all ears.
 
I'm just annoyed at that little hand wave Adelina did during her spiral. Like really? You're going to reward that? If Gracie did her fist pumps she would have bronze lol
 
USA TODAY:

Official says judges slanted toward Adelina Sotnikova


An Olympic judge who was not on the women's panel, who spoke on the condition of anonymity due to the sensitive nature of the issue, said Sotnikova, "was not worthy of the marks she got. The Russian audience for sure influenced her marks."

The judge said Italy's Carolina Kostner should have been "1 to 1.5 points" better than Sotnikova on each program component score -- five in all, interpretation, choreography and the like. But the judges actually gave Sotnikova higher component scores.

As for reigning Olympic champion Yuna Kim, the judge said: "Kim was so much better than Adelina in all aspects. Both Kostner and Kim were better than Adelina."

http://www.usatoday.com/story/sport...-olympics-adelina-sotnikova-yuna-kim/5680717/
 
One judge, Alla Shekhovtseva, is married to Valentin Piseev, former president of the Russian Figure Skating Federation and its current general director. Another, Yuri Balkov of Ukraine, was suspended one year for being part of a result-fixing affair in 1998.

One is a clear conflict of interest. The other is akin to having a bank rehire an employee caught for embezzling.

“Would you rather have an idiot acting as a judge than a good one who is a relative of the manager of a federation?” Cinquanta said. “It is far more important to have a good judge than a possible conflict of interest.

“I can’t suspend a person for life for a minor violation. (Balkov) is a matter for the Ukraine federation, because they chose to send him.”
 
Dick Button:

His thoughts on yesterday’s upset:

“I have absolutely no complaint whatsoever about this. In fact, I think it is one of the best occurrences to happen in the world of skating. I’ll tell you exactly why: because if, maybe, enough people are outraged by not the fact of who they chose, but the judging environment that was there.”

“Look, I don’t blame the marking that was there. I don’t blame the result. I just hope that there’s enough complaint about it that the real matter will erupt. Finally, the sport should get itself in order.”

On what he considers a flawed scoring system:

“Nobody stops to realize that it isn’t the figure skaters that control this, and they say, ‘Change the judging system.’ You aren’t gonna be able to change the judging system unless you change the structure. The [International Skating Union] is controlled by a speed skater. Guess who it was that created the new judging system? It was a speed skater. He wants everything to be measured as it is, and why does he want everything to be measured? Because, very clearly, he doesn’t want a new scandal, like Salt Lake. So he now runs the ISU until 2016, which is too late to do anything of major change before the next Olympics. By the way, there are many good things in this judging system, many good things, and many good things in the old system. But the two have to be carefully and cleanly brought together, the good out of each and the bad out of each.”

On his unapologetic stance on Olympic judging:

“I have loved the world of skating for too long to count, and I am wearing my sassy pants today. When you get to be my age, you can say what you want, when you want, and the heck with whether anybody else likes it or not!”

More at the Source: http://hereandnow.wbur.org/2014/02/21/dick-button-skating
 
NBC Nightly News has reported the controversy tonight with Scott Hamilton set the tone. Scott said the judges were right about the placement. They have rewarded the most athletic skater, while YuNa's skating was beautiful.

Sorry but the public doesn't care what Scott has to say, they have their own eyes and don't need propaganda.
 
Sorry but the public doesn't care what Scott has to say, they have their own eyes and don't need propaganda.

Yeah ever since he helped to self create the SLC debacle he has become irrelevant, since people know all his word can do is bring harm to an already largely damaged (thanks to him) sport. The horrid new judging system we have is completely his and Bezic's fault to begin with, so who cares what they have to say on anything.
 
Back
Top