guinevere said:
And finally, Fantasia's non-singing attitude is losing me quickly. Her clear disdain at being lumped in a group with John and JPL was totally classless. I'm guessing she though it was the bottom group, but that doesn't excuse her behaviour. I think this is what will cost Fantasia the game, not her singing (well, the "yea yea yea"s will have something to do with it too).
And, based on his short solo in the group number, I wish that John had gotten to sing "Daniel" last night. It sounded like a good match for his voice and even his Teen Martin style.
guinevere
I thought so, too, when JPL started singing it, but when I heard John, well, it seems like so few songs really fit with his natural style, and "Daniel" sounded so good coming out of him (at least for that line) that I thought he should've had it. But it would have been a good choice for either of them.JonnyCoop said:re. "Daniel": Actually, JPL started that one off, and I was actually thinking that's the song HE should have picked...
I don't hate John at all. As I've said repeatedly, I think he seems like a really nice guy, and he was one of my favorites from the audition rounds. But the promise he showed in early rounds has not come through. What I 'hate with a passion' is people who call themselves his fans, who vote for him, while admitting that he is not singing well in this competition. I feel sorry for John that people who allegedly support him are putting him through this.Tonichelle said:can I just say that I really think it's funny that all of you hate JS with a passion... and yet he's doing so well... and not all of us are in it for some sort of sex appeal (quite frankly his face looks like a 12 year olds... I find nothing attractive about him)... and others--like myself--actually vote because he's different.
Pati said:IMO, popularity is as much a part of the package as talent. John does have a nice singing voice, but he just hasn't been showing that in this competition. His best performance was his audition, and since then its been downhill. To be a singing idol of any type, you have to sing well consistantly. I think there should be 1 vote and only one vote per phone number. Too much is riding on this for too many hopefuls, and to lose because someone thinks so and so is cute is wrong. After all, this is a singing contest the last time I looked.
As usual, that's just my opinion.
THIS WAS NEVER POP IDOL! You want POP IDOL go to Brittan... this is AMERICAN IDOL which means ALL STYLES ARE WELCOME!
With John S. there's nothing wrong with his look other than he is just SOOOO clean cut.