I haven't read your posts so I don't know how you fellow posters reacted to this, but I've just watched the Shibs' FD and I found it absolutely magnificent Then I saw the score and I couldn't believe it (one judge gave them 9s, so at least I'm not the only one :dance... I think it could very well be my favourite program of theirs ever: finally something sophisticated, mature, completely different from what everyone else is doing!
I am with you but it is a program very criticized.