Unfortunately, your entire argument is based solely on fantasies and guesswork. You accuse publicly without the slightest basis and speak in the same breath of honor. Excuse me, but that is really a paradox and I hope that in real life you will not hold an office in which you have to decide human fate.
You have to be blind in both eyes so as not to see who is throwing whom into chaos.
Let's take a look at the facts for a change instead of spreading rumors about the alleged (!) Pitfalls and interests with which the evil AoP is plunging the poor Kostornaya family into misery.
Alena knocked on Plushenko's door as a supplicant via Rozanov.
He asked that a potential transition should be thoroughly reconsidered.
Result: Kostornaya leaves her old team outside of the transfer window for reasons that have not yet been clarified.
AoP takes them on, although Sambo70 continues to get state funding.
AoP gives free of charge:
- your dream coach (almost as a personal coach)
- as much ice time as you want
- a total of 4 programs as desired
- as many costumes
- a well-known foreign choreographer
- medical care
- your own house directly at the base
- Sponsorship agreements
In return, Alyona gives (presumably):
- the assurance to train for a defined period of time at AoP and to compete for AoP competitions.
Sounds to me like a more than fair deal and you will not find a bank in this world that offers you such conditions, because from a purely financial perspective, AoP bore 100% of the financial risk!
If you stick to the agreement, everything is free of charge, if you break the agreement, you will reimburse the costs.
Obviously, one contract partner kept his promises and the other did not. And if the "free of charge" was tied to a certain period of time (I think there is no doubt about it), then Alyona and her mother were aware of this fact and they have decided in full health to enter into this deal.
I cannot see any unethical behavior, on the contrary.
There is really nothing more to say here. At least not for people who think logically without rose-colored Alyona fan glasses.
Wanna talk facts vs guesswork? Let’s do that.
- Rozanov wasn’t her personal coach, he still has other groups he’s teaching, adults, juniors and novices, and pre-novices.
- there were reports about lack of ice and students leaving because of that, so it also isn’t a fact that she had as much ice as she wanted
- do we even know whether those numerous programs and costumes was what SHE asked for and weren’t Plushenko’s decision? We don’t know that, do we?
We also don’t know whether IF Aliona did leave later, she would’ve made it out without these financial penalties. You haven’t seen the contract to say so, neither did I. So I guess it isn’t as obvious that she could’ve left without financial losses even if she stayed longer. Do we know how these clauses were written and that Aliona’s mom was aware about these potential problems? We don’t.
We also don’t even know if Aliona wasn’t paying a penny for those services before, because Plushenko can claim so, but he’s been caught lying several times, so it means nothing.
Artist’s contracts are notoriously one-sided in Russia and Yana, as a producer, would know how to draft a contract in her favor.
so much for your “facts”.
it doesn’t matter if this is Aliona or not. Had Sasha or any other skater found themselves in the same situation, my opinion on this matter wouldn’t change.
Better give us another conspiracy theory, you were already on your way to do so
