- Joined
- Jul 17, 2018
I vote for Josefin Taljegard! But Natasha McKay would be fine too, I enjoyed her at Finlandia.I vote for Kailani Craine for skate america, she is fun to watch and I don't have see her new program yet.![]()
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I vote for Josefin Taljegard! But Natasha McKay would be fine too, I enjoyed her at Finlandia.I vote for Kailani Craine for skate america, she is fun to watch and I don't have see her new program yet.![]()
A speedy recovery to Yi Zhu! I wonder if Kailani Craine can be invited in her place? Or Natasha McKay? Or Yuhana Yokoi, if she's doing Canada and there are only two JPN women in SA? It's on such a short notice, but hopefully a substitute can be found.
I vote for Kailani Craine for skate america, she is fun to watch and I don't have see her new program yet.![]()
Unfortunately none of Kailani, Josefin or Natasha are on the replacement list because none of them were in the top 75 on the SB best list last season (and none have won a Challenger this fall like Rinka). Josefin was 78th, Kailani was 81st and Natasha was 84th. Sometimes they make exceptions when it's a last minute replacement, but I wouldn't expect it.I vote for Josefin Taljegard! But Natasha McKay would be fine too, I enjoyed her at Finlandia.


It is very upsetting. I wish Yuhana got Skate America. The men's spot for SA, could it have been a visa issue or just not being able to get to Boston in less than a weeks time?Good to see vacated spots filled promptly, and more skaters getting their chances.
However, JSF's unfairness is now even more obvious, as their weakest top man just got two GP *and* a Challenger, while the other men, save Kazuki who also got lucky, got a big fat ZERO Challengers, and will sorely miss the points and reputation they could easily have had. This makes me so angry.
The same happened in women.
If anyone here genuinely cares for the Japanese skaters in general, please let's remember the names of all who were wronged this year by their own Fed (who should have been making sure their skaters get the most opportunities, like every other Fed): Mai, Rino, Rion, Yuhana, Kao, Sena, Shun, Sota, and Tatsuya. I'm not going to forget this anytime soon.![]()
It is very upsetting. I wish Yuhana got Skate America. The men's spot for SA, could it have been a visa issue or just not being able to get to Boston in less than a weeks time?
Yes, was it easier for Koshiro and that's why he got it. I love Shun, and to think I could have seen him live.I don't understand? The spot has just been filled by Koshiro. Or do you mean it would be hard to get there from Japan?
Shun already has two GP assignments, if you mean that you wish he'd gotten the SA vacancy.Yes, was it easier for Koshiro and that's why he got it. I love Shun, and to think I could have seen him live.
It is my understanding of GP series that it is actually the organizing federation that makes the invites... so in this case, Skate America. They could have even replaced Yuma with a skater from another country... So I am not sure how JSF is responsible here. (Though, I agree they haven't been generous with their skaters for the Challenger Series, to say the least).However, JSF's unfairness is now even more obvious
I was only talking about Challengers.It is my understanding of GP series that it is actually the organizing federation that makes the invites... so in this case, Skate America. They could have even replaced Yuma with a skater from another country... So I am not sure how JSF is responsible here. (Though, I agree they haven't been generous with their skaters for the Challenger Series, to say the least).

Peng/Jin are out of both their GPs, due to Jin suffering from tendonitis
Holichenko/Darenskyi are also out of GP Espoo.
I hope Efimova/Blommaert are able to fill one of the spots. Based on their Challenger scores, they could challenge for a medal/a place in the final, but currently are only assigned to Skate Canada.Sad about the withdraws. There is now two spots open in pairs at Espoo I suppose. Does Swedish twins have another spot? If not, could Finland invite them as host spot? Who else is there possible without spot who could replace the missing pairs? I love pairs and I can accept anyone, just hope to see full field.
Efimova is born in Finland, it is very likely they get the spot then.I hope Efimova/Blommaert are able to fill one of the spots. Based on their Challenger scores, they could challenge for a medal/a place in the final, but currently are only assigned to Skate Canada.
Crafoord/Crafoord and Valesi/Piazza currently have 1 spot each (both were at Skate America) so could be in line for a second assignment? Osipova/Epstein are also a possible option, they don't yet have any assignments.