both schools are very different. Carol and John create the partnerships and nurture them and develop them.... IAM doesn't create the partnerships usually (with skaters from abroad) . The skaters go to them. If the Lanes had as many teams and as much success as IAM, perhaps some international teams may feel like going there too more often ??? I just don't think it's fair to compare the two schools because they are completely different.I love Carol and Jon Lane. They are great coaches. And I love the way that, despite being based in Canada for so long, they haven't forgotten where they came from. They take an interest in what is happening in the British Ice Dancing scene, and when they spot up and coming talent, they take them under their wings and nurture it.
The thing that frustrates me is that they all end up skating for Canada. That's one thing that I prefer about the Montréal setup. They also take in talented Ice Dancers from elsewhere the world, but they don't all end up skating for Canada. Most continue to represent their own country.
Ah, I didn't realise that that was the reason. I thought they had just got so frustrated with always playing second-fiddle to Gabrielle and Guillaume. Let's face it, although being team-mates to the stand-out partnership in the world pretty much guarantees you slots, it must be so demoralising to be constantly behind them. Especially for a partnership that is as good as they are. In most countries, they would be the #1 partnership.
Although they are now in a bigger and deeper field, which makes it more difficult to get assignments, at least in Canada they are in a field where they can actually fight with other partnerships of their own level. That way, they are able to gauge where they were at earlier in the season, and work on where they have to improve before doing any international assignments.
It's making them better Ice Dancers. And in the long run, it will be better for them than staying in France.
CaroLiza_fan
Regarding French Ice dance, it's always been strong... Pretty much every generation they have a great team. At this point in time, if MJ and Romain had no reasons to move to Canada and had stayed there, they would be training hard not to get caught by Lopareva Brissaud, and Demougeot Le Mercier. The field is not as deep in France but there are many strong contenders to push a team like Lauriault Le Gac. It would be worth your time to listen to some of their interviews. They are very clear : their move to Canada is all about establishing their lives in Montreal and not about competition... They love the sport and they have made life choices allowing them to integrate it within their work and study paths... It doesn't seem to me that they are hoping for spots or anything... Playing second fiddles to Guillaume and Gabby is probably better than playing 4th or 5th to Piper and Paul, FSB, Lala, and so on... I like them, but I doubt they will ever be first chair on the Canadian scene, and it seems fine by them