I don't think she was underscored in PCS. Her skate, albeit her magnificent SS, was a bit rough and not her best.
If anything, the Lutz was flat.
But Alyona, hands down, won this event. I'm excited to see her progress and will most definitely support her until she retires.
I totally agree with you on the PCS. As much as I think that Aliona should deserve the highest PCS when she gets a program worthy of her and skates her best, she clearly wasn't at her best here. She didn't have the same energy and commitment to the program that she had in France, and she had a noticeable break in her program with the step-out, yet her PCS did go up relative to IDF. Even Ambesi, who is an Aliona super-fan, only thinks she deserves 73-74 for her FS (vs like 38 for her SP), so I think what she got here is fair. :yes:
About the lutz, I'm not so sure. In the program and replay it looked ok to me--obviously not a deep edge, but not flat either. It's obvious she worked hard on this over the off-season, and when she's calm and concentrates, it seems she gets a deep outside edge that rolls to a slightly outside edge when she takes off. But when she's nervous (like in IDF SP) she has a tendency to revert to her old habits. So although she didn't get any edge calls here, I'm sure this is something she'll be concentrating on in her future performances. :yes:
I will continue to support Aliona too (though it wreaks havoc on my sleep schedule and mental health)!
**
The judge-by-judge comparison on the scores is pretty interesting!
In the SP, unsurprisingly the Russian judge scored her at 88, actually the
Japanese judge was the most generous one and scored her at 89.44!
https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1197881207595425792
Yeah, the Japanese just really love Aliona.
In the FS, the Russian judge wayy overscored her compared to the others. The Japanese judge actually scored Rika ahead of Aliona, but still managed to score Aliona at 157.83 (i.e. above what she actually got).
https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1198241303022198784
Also, if we want to talk about combined best SP and FS scores so far, who do you think comes out on top?
https://twitter.com/SkatingScores/status/1198438241134940160
**
ACK, they just interviewed Aliona at the gala but I couldn't hear what they were saying over the @#%$ Zamboni!!

Will have to rewatch later.