(First of all, I have to say I'm surprised to learn you aren't or weren't a figure skater! I thought for sure you were since you know about edges and such .... I'm still learning...
)Since you brought up gymnastics ...
... I'll make this point: You say a skater who can't always land her jumps might as well be a ballet dancer. Well, I say a skater who can jump but looks awful during the rest of her program might as well be a gymnast .
... or some other kind of athlete.Also, I don't know about your weight argument ... Kim Yuna looks like a total waif and she is the one of the most powerful jumpers in history.
I do think Sasha would have made gorgeous ballerina. But it's not like she's some kind of failed figure skater.
If she WANTS to be on par with the top figure skaters?? She WAS on par with the top figure skaters!!
I'm really not sure she was that much of a slouch technically. Were her jumps really that bad? Did she really fall or stumble more often than Joannie? When Sasha won silver at 2004 and 2005 worlds, her programs were nearly perfect. She didn't actually fall - just stumbled once or twice. It's the same sort of peformance Joannie gave to win HER world silver medal. But for Joannie, the peformance was considered awesome and her silver medal a victory. When Sasha was near perfect, such as in 2005 worlds, people thought she "crumbled" because she barely lost the gold. Someone said in another thread that Sasha is held to a different standard. I think it's true.
. 
