Re: Among jumps of the same type...
sarahmistral said:
what makes a flip harder than a toe loop? And what makes a loop harder than a salchow? The lutz I understand the most b/c of the entry edge, but I'm curious about the other jumps that are similar in takeoff except for the particular leg, etc.
The way I understand it:
A waltz is the easiest because it is only half a turn in the air.
The toe loop and salchow are next, because both involve jumping from one foot to the other, which is easier than jumping and landing on the same foot. I learnt the salchow first, but some people learn the toe loop first. There is also a similarity between them and the waltz jump, so it seems easier to learn them next. It seems to be quite interchangeable which is easiest (although I think a salchow is given slightly more inder COP).
The loop and flip are next, because both those jumps involve jumping and landing on the same foot, which is more difficult to learn than jumping off one foot and landing on the other. I think the loop is considered slightly easier, although personally I found the flip easier when I was learning them. As with the others, there's a similarity in the mechanics of the two jumps (after you pick in on the flip, you basically jump off that toe - the same foot as for a loop).
The lutz is next hardest because it winds up in one direction and then you jump in the opposite direction (or you're supposed to anyway, lol).
The axel is hardest because it's an extra half turn in the air (and a lot of people find the forward takeoff tricky).
However, especially when it gets to triples, the order of difficulty often isn't quite the same as the order in which a certain skater will find them difficult. Mostly I'd say it's the same, but several skaters find a more difficult jump easier than one of the easier ones. It's just preference.
Hope that helps