- Joined
- Mar 14, 2007
Not really. If you lose it too quickly it puts a different strain on your heart. I think the most important thing is to keep moving. If you lose your mobility things get much more difficult very quickly.
Eteri Tutberidze to became a mentor in a weight loss reality show
- Thread starter Rebecca Moose
- Start date
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2007
That is such an excellent idea Let her become a TV star, leave the kids alone.
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2007
@Diana Delafield said
"Sorry, I'm baffled by the math here. Is that a typo for 241 lbs? Because 241 kg = 531 lbs. According to this study: https://pubmed.ncbi.nim.nih.gov/34264558 about the prevalence of obesity in Russia, a BMI of over 30 would be considered obese, and that the majority of females who fell into this category in their study were middle-aged women in rural areas, not teenage girls in cities. Say the woman was my height, 163 cm, then a BMI of 30 would be about 79.3 kg or 175 lbs. (My BMI is 19, but that's not relevant here, just shows the range the authors of the study used.)
How many girls weighing 531 lbs are they going to be able to find for the show? That's the size of someone you read about who has to be taken to the hospital, so firefighters have to break down an outer wall of a house to winch the person out of bed and onto a reinforced truck for transport, because they couldn't get out of bed and couldn't fit through the doorway of their bedroom. (I know the whole BMI idea has its detractors, but it was used in the Russian paper and I was using the numbers to extrapolate poundage or kilograms.)
Just curious about the numbers, in an academic sort of way. "
There's a US show called "My 600 Pound Life" which my sister used to watch. It's super exploitative. But usually if you're 531 you don't need the door to be broken down. That's more towards the 700-800 lb range. And every single one of these people has been sexually molested. They need a LOT of therapy in addition to medically supervised weight loss. What they would not need would be Eteri.
"Sorry, I'm baffled by the math here. Is that a typo for 241 lbs? Because 241 kg = 531 lbs. According to this study: https://pubmed.ncbi.nim.nih.gov/34264558 about the prevalence of obesity in Russia, a BMI of over 30 would be considered obese, and that the majority of females who fell into this category in their study were middle-aged women in rural areas, not teenage girls in cities. Say the woman was my height, 163 cm, then a BMI of 30 would be about 79.3 kg or 175 lbs. (My BMI is 19, but that's not relevant here, just shows the range the authors of the study used.)
How many girls weighing 531 lbs are they going to be able to find for the show? That's the size of someone you read about who has to be taken to the hospital, so firefighters have to break down an outer wall of a house to winch the person out of bed and onto a reinforced truck for transport, because they couldn't get out of bed and couldn't fit through the doorway of their bedroom. (I know the whole BMI idea has its detractors, but it was used in the Russian paper and I was using the numbers to extrapolate poundage or kilograms.)
Just curious about the numbers, in an academic sort of way. "
There's a US show called "My 600 Pound Life" which my sister used to watch. It's super exploitative. But usually if you're 531 you don't need the door to be broken down. That's more towards the 700-800 lb range. And every single one of these people has been sexually molested. They need a LOT of therapy in addition to medically supervised weight loss. What they would not need would be Eteri.
Similar threads
- Locked
