It is obviously true that Michelle is amazingly popular. Her popularity is based on different criterea that we use for many athletes especially skaters. It has usually been the Olympic Gold medalists that the public has embraced. But I think they embrace Michelle not only because of her amazing talent and Titles, but because of her longevity and her grace when winning or losing. She is the household name, to the average american who is not deep into the skating world, when it comes to ladies figure skating. While this year she did not have the the accomplishments she has had in previous years, she did accomplish winning her 8th National Championship THIS year. That in and of itself is amazing in any sport. Not many athletes ever have a year during which they prove they are the best our Nation has to offer for their eigth year. If you read the criterea the nominations were was based on, it was especially focused on this being the year she was crowned for the eighth time - and given that I don't see it surprising at all she came in as runner-up. Seriously doubt that 8 years from now Carly Patterson will be the Ladies National Gymnastics Champion. And while I am not saying in any way that a one time great performance at the right time time doesn't deserve the highest of recognition, I think a decade of brilliant results does as well.