I think Top 6 for the Shibs is a real possibility, depending on how they skate and how others do. Where do they go from here is tough to say. I'll be very frank, there are things that will count against them and I am not going to be PC about it:
1) They will never be seen as a couple because they are brother and sister team and look way too alike, even more so than the Kerrs who can still pass for strangers, but not the Shibs
2) They still look like kids
3) They are not good looking enough in the world of Ice Dance
On Point 3, maybe they will once they mature and become adults but at this point, the lack of a handsome man + attractive woman pairing can hurt your chance in the long run - yes, looks count for a great deal in Ice Dance no matter how wrong this may sound
Your opinions are certainly interesting, and I have no problem in you not being PC. I just have slightly different opinions.
1) It's true that they are very alike and would not be considered non-relations. It means they have to be mindful about kind of pieces they dance. This could be a limitation.
On the other hand, they have several things going for them: they have excellent timing (per Doris), good work ethics, partnering skills and togetherness (per Colleen), and a top-notch coaching team who could tailor programs to get around sibling issues .
Those assets should be able to propel the Shibs to be one of the top teams in the world.
2) Let's face it - they are only 16 & 19. And Asians in general look younger than Caucasians. Remedy - give them time to mature!
My wish lists: For Maia to drink gallons and gallons of milk this Summer so she grows taller again the next season ; for Alex to grow and mature enough that I can see his "five o'clock shadow'' at least once!
3) Beauty is in the eye of the beholder - I personally think they are plenty attractive. Beyond physical attributes though, they have very appealing qualities - be it the sheer joy in their dancing expression, precise and quiet skating contributing to their trademark old-fashioned elegance, and beautifully matching leg lines and serene unison, which are, perhaps, only siblings can achieve.
One interesting aspect of the Shibs having Japanese heritage - I'm not surprised that some judges (out of being "PC") may root for them, thereby ensuring at least one "non-Caucasian team" among top ten. I personally think that kind of motive is an insult to this very hard working and talented team, and they certainly is the first-tier team solely on their own merit, but their is no accounting for some judges motives.
Last edited: