? R&J2 sure, but Chopin? I really think the transition and choreo matched perfectly and were highlighted by the music. In PW less highlighting, but still everything matched to the music, though everything he does isn't at the forefront, I think because it's designed to make everything look easy and cool, though I see how that may miss the mark and look busy/not connected.
Here is what I consider to be good choreography. The artist/performer has a clear (positive) message/story to share. He/she expresses it very effectively through the choreography. So every move in the choreography, as well as the techniques, body language, facial expression and so on, should have a meaning and purpose, i.e. to help express that message or to tell the story. If the move has no purpose, it is just filler and should not be included. The program doesn’t have to the most difficult program, but it should be meaningful and can move/inspire the audience in a positive way. I believe for every artist/performer regardless which art form they are using, their ultimate goal is to move and inspire the audience positively.
So when I look at choreography, I would first try to see if the choreographer has a clear message or story to tell. If the idea is very vague or abstract, then I don’t think the program would be very good even if the performer is technically excellent. I do find some music very vague and abstract. I don’t consider this kind of music to be suitable for choreography purpose. In general, I find dramatic music and dance music are good choices. Portraying a character also helps connecting to the audience strongly. In a live performance setting, I think the performer should exaggerate his moves and not perform with subtlety because the audiences are so far away from you, they cannot see or feel much if you perform with subtlety.
Based on my criteria, here is my ranking of Yuzuru’s competitive programs.
R&J 1.0 > POTO>PW>Chopin>NDP>R&J2.0
R&J 1.0: Strong character and expression. Every move is meaningful and enhances the story telling. Probably the best figure skating program I’ve seen.
POTO: Yuzuru is very committed to portray the Phantom. Each move is well timed with the music. Most elements enhance the story-telling well.
PW: I could tell he is trying to be cool. Most of the big moves (some smaller moves seem a little off) highlight the music and made him look easy and cool. It’s not a bad program. But I don’t like the music.
Chopin: I could not understand what the music is trying to convey. It’s too abstract. I could not tell what Yuzuru is trying to convey either. I actually don’t know if he is trying to express anything in particular. The elements and transitions are well timed with the music, but I don’t feel any of the elements or transition has much purpose or meaning because there is nothing clearly conveyed. But he is technically excellent. I do appreciate his technical skills and performance style in this program.
NDP and R&J2.0: I don’t know what to say about these two programs. I could not understand either. The programs are physically too demanding. He is too exhausted to perform. I ranked NDP higher than R&J 2.0 because the R&j 2.0 costume is …
I think in terms of program difficulty, the ranking is probably in the reverse order. I wish they can limit the number of transitions in a program. If you include thousands of them in a program, there is no way you can make all of them meaningful. Most of them would look like fillers.
I wonder how everyone else would rank Yuzu’s competitive programs.
---------------
About falls: IA, I'm fine for 2 points deduction, but anything more than that both puts the system off balance as you said and also makes falls punished disproportionately to stepouts etc. increasing serial deductions are pointless and no points is ridic.
2pt deductions seem a little harsh for jumps with lower base values, e.g. 3T and 3S, after the deductions, you would get 0 points. I would give 1 point deduction for undisruptive falls and 2point for disruptive falls. It can encourage skaters to get up quickly if they do fall, and hopefully not distort the incentive for trying risky elements.
------------------
ETA: don't worry youre not posting too much, this kind of discussion is good esp compared to conspiracy theories/freaking out (not to put down anyone who does)
We have some news update, so I don’t think fans will freak out as much now.
Last edited:

Well...thats random. Should be fun though
: Seems like an older picture, but I've never seen it before.