- Joined
- Jan 17, 2014
I would say her "inconsistency" has largely been the result of trying to do the most difficult programs ever attempted. Where would everyone else be if they tried to do a 3Axel in every program, plus a second 3Axel or a 3Flip+3Loop in every Long Program?
While I admire her personal conviction, it's still a fact that her programs are hit and miss. The most extreme was in Sochi 2014 where the SP was a big miss followed by arguably the best ever LP I had ever seen by a lady skater although the judging of her LP left a lot to be desired.
This somewhat reminded me of the early 2000s when Irina Slutskaya was competing fiercely with Michelle Kwan. Knowing that she will never have the level of softness, presentation and refined lines as Kwan, Slutskaya repeatedly went for tough combos and difficult spin positions. How successful was she? Not often on the biggest competitions, although she more often won in smaller competitions. The 6.0 era simply didn't have enough granularity to differentiate the technical elements but as Kwan was always ahead on the presentation, Slutskaya had little choice except to try to push her tech levels so high that judges simply could not ignore it, which resulted in a lot of wonky landings and inconsistency. CoP arrived just in time to allow her the max out the last and best years since her tricks and difficulty in spins were exactly what CoP rewarded.
In Mao's case, I think it was more a personal battle to better herself rather than fighting Yuna which led to the toughies. That inconsistency for whatever reason just made me take her off my personal all round skater. Of course there are many consistent skaters like Miyahara or Medvedeva but they don't qualify due to poor (albeit improving) jumps (Miyahara) and mediocre SS + skating through music (Evgenia).