Mrs P, you analysis in post #17 is excellent.
Not reflected in that are up and comers... specifically Nathan Chen, and who knows where he's going to be in a year or two.
There was a thread just like this a year ago. Many people vented their frustrations at seeing him consistently bomb with calls of the Fumie Syndrome. The thread was long. This year.... people are just worried about his mental health.
Let's not forget:
Without Jeremy and Max, the U.S. men would have only two slots at Worlds this year.
And the Four Continents silver medalist Josh Farris would not be going to Worlds (except in the unlikely event that USFS had given the cold shoulder to Rippon).
The circumstances of this year's Nationals sadly were unique for Jeremy, given that his father had just died.
Give the guy a break. If he decides to continue his competitive career, I wish him all the best. If he decides not to, I wish him all the best.
I'm sorry he feels he has to continue. Everybody should go out on their own terms but how low does he need to go before he realizes that ship has sailed!!! I think Jeremy is a very classy, beautiful skater but his programs did nothing for me this year and it's the same ol' same ol' - and he hasn't really improved much in the last couple of years. I think he'll be a fantastic show skater and I'll enjoy watching every minute, but Jeremy is a mediocre competitor and I really don't want to see him take the place of an up and comer with a future.
Hmm, interesting to read this thread and see the feedback seems more positive now than it was last year...
If he wants to keep going, it's his business.
OTOH, maybe he can have a Sergei Voronov revival. Sergei is also 28, but I'd argue he's the best we've ever seen him in his career.
He's 27...but who's counting. But I think Sergei's mental game is a lot stronger than Jeremy's ever was, or ever will be. Of course Jeremy can compete as long as he wants - it's his life. I don't see him as a threat to anyone else.