- Joined
- Mar 7, 2015
i am curious to hear your take on giving out the host spot to Kate Wang instead of anyone from Canada ...
2022–23 Canadian Figure Skating
- Thread starter Colonel Green
- Start date
- Status
- Joined
- Nov 30, 2016
Well, they didn't give Kate a host spot, technically. They chose not the use the host spot after the women they'd picked withdrew, and then picked someone on the replacement list rather than leave the spot empty. Functionally, it's pretty much the same thing, I know, but I don't think the focus should be on Kate Wang and her merits (not saying you were, just that I've seen that).
I'd have preferred they give it to a Canadian women, of course, but I also understand that the options were limited. I think that if Lia Pereira hadn't already competed on the JGP, if they'd known this spot was open a few months ago, they might have given it to her. She's the oldest of our JGP women, she has some experience having done the JGP and JW, and they've given her a senior CS assignment this fall. But she's not available. Nor are Sara-Maude Dupuis or Justine Miclette. We know Kaiya's been injured. If she's ready to go and wanted to do the GP, then I would rather have her than Kate, obviously. But she's just coming back after multiple injuries and a long time not competing. I know she did a domestic comp this weekend, but that's not the same as a GP. So maybe a spot at SC wouldn't be the best thing for her. Hard to say without knowing the details.
You've suggested Fiona Bombardier I believe. I don't know if I'd be in favour of that. I definitely want to see our skaters get more experience and opportunities, but I also think you have to be careful about throwing people into the deep end. According to her ISU bio, Fiona has had one international competition, and never even done a JGP. Yes that's on SC, but going from one single junior B event to a senior grand prix would be a big jump. She's been competing junior domestically this summer and had decent results (139.48 at the NextGen simulation, 130.75 in Quebec), but not as good as several of the other junior women. They aren't available because they've done the JGP, but the point is that I'd be concerned about taking someone with almost no international experience, who wasn't even at the top of our juniors, and throwing her into a senior GP. Maybe it would go fine and be really valuable experience for her. If they'd picked her I would be supportive, but I also understand why they wouldn't want to go that direction.
So that leaves the senior women. We haven't seen Alicia Pineault, and I think they'd be considering her if she was available. So I'm assuming she wasn't an option. So there are the summer competitions. Amanda Tobin got 152.98 at the July Skate Ontario event (when you combine SP and FS), and scored 132.38 at Cranberry International. Katherine Medland-Spence got 148.04 at the August event and 123.03 at the July event. Audréanne Foster got 148.83 at Souvenir Georges-Éthier, 151.15 at the Quebec summer event skating junior, and 116.78 at the NextGen event. Those are the three who stood out to me when looking at all the summer results (+ Uliana Shiryaeva, but she's not been released by Russia). Audréanne has done a JGP, and has at least done a senior domestic competition, but you could have the same concerns with her as with Fiona. They could have picked Amanda or Katherine. That's probably what I'd do.
I think, to me, the bigger problem is not sending these skaters out to Challengers and Senior Bs. I understand why they might decide none of them are ready for a senior GP, based on their scores (I mention scores because if someone was out getting huge domestic scores, they'd send her regardless) and lack of international experience. Thinking that maybe the GP isn't the best place to start getting that experience. I think that would be a valid position, if if I didn't necessarily agree. But I at least want to see more CS and B event assignments. Sylvia from Unseen Skaters posted on FSU that she thinks Fiona will be going to IceChallenge in Austria in November, based on an Instagram story from her coaches (not clear on whether it'll be as a junior or senior). Skate Canada also has Warsaw Cup and Golden Spin on the international assignments page, so hopefully some other women will be sent out (seniors or juniors). Skate Canada normally sends at least of couple of girls to junior B events in the fall, and they've already given Lia a Challenger (possibly due to her strong result at Cranberry). I'd like to see Justine Miclette get one as well. And hopefully others.
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2015
so we pretty much agree... the simple fact that they are not sending our skaters to challengers means that whenever someone from the national team is injured and cannot compete, Skate Canada is screwed....
it's two spots this year that are gone... the one in women, and the one in pairs... i am okay with the one in pairs because i understand that they are doing their best here.... with so many teams retiring and the last minute drop out of Walsh. But yeah... women, just send one... and tell her, we just don't want to waste the spot so enjoy yourself... do a nice SP and don't worry about placement.. it's experience
Even when they sent "good skaters" or more experienced ones, they finished in the bottom.. so nothing new there I don't think Fiona or Amanda or Katherine would be too upset.... I think it's important to frame these experiences.... "you got nothing to lose" is sometimes a good approach... but oh well.. what is done is done.
it's two spots this year that are gone... the one in women, and the one in pairs... i am okay with the one in pairs because i understand that they are doing their best here.... with so many teams retiring and the last minute drop out of Walsh. But yeah... women, just send one... and tell her, we just don't want to waste the spot so enjoy yourself... do a nice SP and don't worry about placement.. it's experience
Even when they sent "good skaters" or more experienced ones, they finished in the bottom.. so nothing new there I don't think Fiona or Amanda or Katherine would be too upset.... I think it's important to frame these experiences.... "you got nothing to lose" is sometimes a good approach... but oh well.. what is done is done.
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2015
only explanation i am willing to accept
some sort of swap.. i don't recall when L/E got that spot... was it before or after they got W/M's spot?
Very thorough analysis. Just to add… I think athletes like Kaiya don’t move up to Seniors is because she is more competitive in the Juniors division. This year, there is only one spot for Worlds, which will most likely go to Maddie. But, there are two spots for Junior Worlds. I think Kaiya is focusing on qualifying to Junior Worlds. By the way, her free skate is really strong. But, she seems to be under rotating her triples and messing up on spins. She should get better as the season progresses.
Also, I just want to mention that I live in BC and there is a new girl from Russia, as you mentioned, Uliana, who skates in the same camp as Kara Yun. They both do 3Lz 3T and I think these two will push each other to improve. Their technical difficulty is there. They just need to work on spins and artistry. It will be interesting to see when Uliana transfers. I think she will be eligible next year. So, Maddie better turn it up. As, there are some eager Juniors and transfers on the horizon.
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2015
Uliana just needs a release... which she doesn't really need because she's never competed internationally.
And as far as Junior worlds are concerned... a skater can do senior GP and do junior worlds... they can even do both junior and senior worlds...
the only combo that is not allowed is JGP and senior GP... so if Ruitter had been in shape, she definitely could have done Skate Canada, and junior worlds.. but at this point, I guess they are focusing on Nationals.
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2015
BTW .. has anyone seen @siberia82 ? I hope she is alright.
Amanda had a good showing in the short at Cranberry- in fact she had the 3rd highest TEC score. Her performance skills will only go up as she gets out in front of international judges more. And like you say 4everchan; as long as they know they are being sent just for experience and not results who does it hurt. And again like you say it is not like they have not sent skaters with more experience like Veronik and Juliane and even Katelyn who finished in the bottom two.But yeah... women, just send one... and tell her, we just don't want to waste the spot so enjoy yourself... do a nice SP and don't worry about placement.. it's experience
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2014
This is completely off topic but.....Genie Bouchard played a great match today. She is definitely still in the "Mix" for the top of the game. She took Olympic Champion Belinda Bencic to the brink this afternoon. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-hwxNSKtoC8
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2015
same coach as nic and jo
Fantastic free programme today at Gdansk - Anthony has phenomenal flexibility and passion. I'm a new fan. He clearly has a lot of fans in the audience, too. Definitely a future star.
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2015
not for worlds but for 4cc
ISU Communication 2488: Four Continents Moved, 2022-23 Technical Minimum Scores — So You Want To Watch Figure Skating
ISU Communication 2488 The 2023 Four Continents Championships (Feb. 7-12) has been moved from Sydney, Australia to Colorado Springs, USA. Technical Minimum Scores, 2023 ISU Championships: 2023 World Championships: Men: 34.00 SP, 64.00 FS Women: 32.00 SP, 53.00 FS Pairs: 29.00 SP, 46.
www.soyouwanttowatchfs.com
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2018
Scott must be thrilled with local Ilderton kids Lewis/McMillan getting that surprise bronze.
Good start to the season for Laurence & Nikolaj, finally surpassing that personal best from three seasons ago.
Good start to the season for Laurence & Nikolaj, finally surpassing that personal best from three seasons ago.
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2015
Maddie will be fine. Gabby will be fine... Everything will be fine
- Status
